A foreign brand can maintain a common law action for passing off in Nigeria without local trademark registration under the Trade Marks Act, provided the foreign claimant establishes existing goodwill or business reputation in Nigeria, deceptive misrepresentation by the defendant, and actual or probable financial damages. Section 3 of the Nigerian Trade Marks Act explicitly preserves the common law tort of passing off, confirming that the absence of statutory trademark registration does not deprive an enterprise of judicial protection against deceptive commercial imitations.
The Classical Trinity of Passing Off in Nigerian Courts
To succeed in a passing off claim without a registered trademark in Nigeria, the foreign brand must satisfy the Federal High Court on the classical trinity established under Nigerian and common law jurisprudence:
- Goodwill and Commercial Reputation: The plaintiff must prove that its name, mark, get-up, packaging, or brand identity has acquired recognizable commercial goodwill among Nigerian consumers.
- Misrepresentation Leading to Confusion: The defendant must have made an unauthorized representation, whether intentional or unintentional, leading the Nigerian public to believe the defendant goods or services are connected to the foreign brand.
- Financial or Reputational Damage: The foreign brand must demonstrate that it has suffered or is reasonably likely to suffer tangible loss of sales, commercial goodwill dilution, or brand degradation.
Establishing Local Goodwill for Foreign Brands
Nigerian courts maintain that goodwill is local and must exist within the territorial borders of Nigeria. However, modern commercial practice acknowledges trans-border reputation. A foreign brand does not need a physical factory or retail branch in Lagos or Abuja to establish goodwill in Nigeria.
A foreign brand can prove Nigerian goodwill by presenting documentary evidence of extensive international advertising accessible in Nigeria, cross-border digital commerce orders shipped to Nigerian addresses, spillover television broadcasts, satellite broadcasts, international travel usage by Nigerians, and partnerships with local distributors or importers. If Nigerian consumers recognize the foreign brand prior to the defendant commercial launch, actionable goodwill exists.
Statutory Differences Between Trademark Infringement and Passing Off
Proprietors must understand the fundamental distinctions between statutory infringement actions and common law passing off:
- Evidential Burden: In a statutory trademark infringement action, producing the CAC-recognized Trademark Registration Certificate issued by the Trademarks Registry in Abuja establishes a prima facie proprietary right. In passing off, the plaintiff bears the heavy evidential burden of demonstrating commercial reputation through financial accounts, advertising expenditure, and consumer surveys.
- Basis of the Right: Trademark infringement protects the exclusive statutory monopoly over the registered mark itself. Passing off protects the business goodwill and prevents unfair competition and deceit.
- Remedial Scope: Both causes of action offer similar final remedies, but passing off requires continuous proof that the public was actually misled or likely to be confused by the similar get-up or trade name.
Court Jurisdiction and Procedural Action Steps
The Federal High Court exercises exclusive civil jurisdiction over all intellectual property claims, corporate names, and passing off disputes in Nigeria pursuant to Section 251(1)(f) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended). Foreign claimants should follow structured legal steps:
- Issuance of Cease-and-Desist Demands: Serve formal legal notice on the infringing party through a licensed Nigerian legal practitioner, putting the infringer on notice and demanding immediate cessation of sales and recall of inventory.
- Filing a Writ of Summons: Institute an action at the Federal High Court supported by a Statement of Claim, witness statements on oath, and certified exhibits demonstrating domestic brand recognition.
- Ex Parte Anton Piller Orders: Where evidence exists that the infringer may conceal or destroy counterfeit goods and production materials, apply urgently for an Anton Piller search and seizure order to enter premises and impound infringing stock.
- Interlocutory Injunction: Secure an interlocutory restraining order preventing the infringer from manufacturing, importing, marketing, or distributing the offending products pending the final determination of the substantive lawsuit.
- Substantive Remedies: Seek permanent injunctions, delivery up of counterfeit materials for destruction, damages for loss of business, or an account of profits earned by the defendant from the unlawful trading.
Protective Business Registrations for Foreign Brands
While passing off protects unregistered marks, relying exclusively on common law remedies creates unnecessary litigation expense and evidentiary complexity. Foreign enterprises trading or intending to trade in Nigeria should immediately register their word marks and device marks with the Trademarks, Patents and Designs Registry, Commercial Law Department, Federal Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment.
Foreign corporate entities should also register their corporate names or incorporate local subsidiaries with the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) under CAMA 2020 to prevent third parties from registering identical company names on the CAC portal.



