No, a Nigerian company cannot issue shares at a discount under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020. Section 146 of CAMA 2020 explicitly declares that it is unlawful for any company limited by shares to issue shares at a discount to their nominal value, completely eliminating the previous exception under the repealed 1990 Act that permitted such issuances with court sanction.
This strict statutory prohibition reinforces the fundamental common law doctrine of capital maintenance. Creditors dealing with a limited liability company look to its issued share capital as the primary cushion for credit repayment. Permitting shares to be allotted below their stated par value would undermine the integrity of the company’s balance sheet and expose third parties to undisclosed financial risk.
The Evolution from CAMA 1990 to CAMA 2020
Under the old regime of Section 121 of CAMA 1990, companies were permitted to issue shares at a discount under strict conditions. A company had to pass a special resolution in general meeting, specify the maximum discount rate, obtain sanction from the Federal High Court, and register the transaction with the CAC.
CAMA 2020 removed that entire framework. Because modern Nigerian companies routinely set their nominal share value at minimal amounts (such as 1 Naira or even 50 Kobo per share), lawmakers concluded that discount allotments were unnecessary, commercially outdated, and prone to accounting abuse.
What Constitutes an Unlawful Discount?
A share is issued at a discount whenever the cash or equivalent consideration received by the company is less than the nominal or par value of that share. For example, if a company has ordinary shares with a nominal value of 1.00 Naira each, allotting those shares to an investor at 0.70 Naira per share represents a 30 Kobo discount and is strictly void under Nigerian law.
This prohibition applies to all categories of share issues:
- Initial subscriptions: Original subscribers signing the memorandum of association must pay full nominal consideration.
- Subsequent allotments: New shares issued to existing members or fresh external investors cannot be priced below nominal value.
- Private placements: Private rounds and institutional debt-to-equity conversions cannot convert debt into equity below the nominal rate.
Lawful Commercial Alternatives Under CAMA 2020
Corporate promoters and company directors looking to incentivize investors or adjust pricing have several legitimate alternatives under Nigerian corporate practice:
- Rights issues priced below current market valuation: A company whose market value sits at 50 Naira per share may offer new shares to existing shareholders at 25 Naira. As long as the offer price remains equal to or above the 1.00 Naira nominal value, the transaction is entirely legal.
- Payment of underwriting commission: Under Section 147 of CAMA 2020, a company may pay a lawful commission not exceeding 10% of the issue price to underwriters or brokers who agree to procure subscriptions.
- Non-cash consideration with independent valuation: Under Section 137 of CAMA 2020, shares may be allotted in exchange for valuable property or services, provided an independent valuer determines that the true market value of the non-cash asset equals or exceeds the nominal value of the shares issued.
- Subdivision of nominal share value: A company can alter its share capital structure by subdividing high-denomination shares into smaller denominations (for example, splitting a 10.00 Naira share into ten 1.00 Naira shares) through an ordinary resolution filed at the CAC.
Comparing Shares at a Discount, at Par, and at a Premium
- Shares at a discount: Issue price is lower than nominal value; strictly prohibited under Section 146 of CAMA 2020.
- Shares at par: Issue price is identical to nominal value; standard baseline under Nigerian corporate practice.
- Shares at a premium: Issue price exceeds nominal value; lawful and encouraged under Section 145, with excess funds transferred to the statutory share premium account.
Legal Sanctions for Violating Section 146
Any allotment purported to be made at a discount is ultra vires and legally void to the extent of the discount. The allottee remains statutorily liable to pay the full nominal balance to the company, and directors who knowingly authorize the illicit allotment face civil liabilities to refund the deficit and administrative fines imposed by the CAC.