No, a Nigerian company cannot pay cash dividends out of unrealized capital profits under Section 427 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 (CAMA 2020). CAMA strictly mandates that distributable profits must consist solely of realized accumulated profits less realized accumulated losses, prohibiting companies from distributing paper asset gains, revaluation surpluses, or speculative book appreciations as cash returns to shareholders.
The cardinal objective of this restriction is capital preservation. A company limited by shares protects its creditors through its equity cushion; permitting distributions based on hypothetical property or investment valuations would compromise financial stability and deceive stakeholders about actual liquidity.
Statutory Framework Governing Distributable Profits
Section 427 of CAMA 2020 establishes unambiguous boundaries on what constitutes legally distributable reserves.
- Realized Profits Rule: Dividends may only be declared and paid out of the company’s realized profits arising from its business transactions or realized capital accretions resulting from actual completed asset disposals.
- Accumulated Losses Deduction: Distributable profits must be calculated net of any realized accumulated losses from previous financial years that have not been written off in a lawful capital reduction.
- Prohibition on Unrealized Surpluses: Revaluation of fixed assets, real estate, or long-term investments that produces a book surplus does not constitute distributable profit. Until the asset is sold in an arm’s-length transaction and cash or settled consideration is received, the gain remains purely unrealized.
The Distinction Between Cash Dividends and Bonus Shares
While unrealized capital profits cannot fund cash dividend disbursements, CAMA 2020 provides a specific, narrow exception for equity capitalization.
- Bonus Share Issuance: Under Section 430 of CAMA 2020, a company may capitalize an unrealized capital profit or revaluation reserve by issuing fully paid bonus shares (scrip dividends) to existing shareholders in proportion to their shareholdings.
- Capital Preservation Rationale: A bonus issue does not extract liquid cash from the company’s bank accounts. Instead, it converts an internal revaluation reserve into permanent paid-up share capital, strengthening the company’s balance sheet equity base rather than depleting it.
- Cash Dividends vs Scrip Dividends: Distributing cash based on paper gains creates severe insolvency risk if market asset values subsequently decline, whereas scrip distributions preserve working liquidity intact.
Director Liability and Unlawful Distributions
Nigerian company law imposes stringent personal liabilities on corporate directors who violate dividend distribution rules.
- Joint and Several Personal Liability: Under Section 431 of CAMA 2020, all directors who knowingly authorize, recommend, or participate in the payment of dividends out of capital or unrealized profits are jointly and severally liable to refund the full amount distributed back to the company.
- Defense of Honest Reliance: A director can only escape personal liability if they prove that they relied in good faith on financial statements prepared by the company’s statutory auditors showing adequate realized profits, and had no reasonable cause to doubt their accuracy.
- Shareholder Repayment Obligation: Shareholders who receive dividends knowing, or having reasonable grounds to believe, that the distribution breached statutory profit rules must return the funds received to the corporate treasury upon demand.
Accounting Standards and IFRS Compliance
Nigerian companies prepare financial accounts in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) as adopted by the Financial Reporting Council of Nigeria (FRCN).
- Other Comprehensive Income (OCI): Fair value adjustments and revaluation gains on property, plant, and equipment under IAS 16 are recognized in Other Comprehensive Income and accumulated in an equity revaluation reserve, rather than the profit and loss account.
- Auditor Scrutiny: Statutory independent auditors must explicitly verify that any dividend recommended by the board of directors is fully backed by realized distributable reserves before signing off on the annual financial statements presented to shareholders at the Annual General Meeting (AGM).
- Solvency Verification: Even when realized profits exist, directors must confirm that paying the dividend will not impair the company’s ability to settle debts as they mature in the regular course of business.
Company boards must maintain rigorous financial records, separating operational trading earnings from asset revaluation accounts to maintain full compliance with CAMA 2020 and avoid severe personal surcharge liabilities.