A proprietor of a registered business name cannot sue for passing off in the Federal High Court unless the claim is tied to an infringement of a registered trademark. Under prevailing Nigerian judicial authorities, an action for pure common law passing off involving an unregistered mark or commercial trading name must be instituted in the High Court of a State or the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory, and the suit must be brought in the personal name of the proprietor trading under the registered business name.
Legal Personality and Capacity of a Registered Business Name
Registration of a business name under Part E of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 does not create an incorporated body with distinct legal personality. Unlike limited liability companies registered under Part B of CAMA 2020, a business name lacks perpetual succession and cannot sue or be sued in its registered name without specific procedural compliance.
Under Nigerian civil procedure rules, where a single proprietor operates under a business name, the action must be commenced in the personal name of the owner, framed as “A.B. trading under the name and style of XYZ Ventures.” Where the business name represents a partnership, court rules generally permit partners to sue in the firm name, but legal liability and proprietary rights remain rooted in the individual partners.
The Constitutional and Statutory Jurisdictional Conflict
Jurisdiction over intellectual property and trade disputes in Nigeria is governed by Section 251(1)(f) of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, as amended. This section grants the Federal High Court exclusive civil jurisdiction over any federal enactment relating to copyright, patent, designs, trademarks, and “passing-off, wrongful user of trade marks, and other related matters.”
Despite this constitutional provision, the Supreme Court of Nigeria has delivered definitive pronouncements regarding the boundary between common law passing off and statutory passing off. In landmark decisions including Patkun Industries Ltd v. Niger Shoes Manufacturing Ltd (1988), Ayman Enterprises Ltd v. Akuma Industries Ltd (2003), and Omnia Nigeria Ltd v. Dykes Industries Ltd (2007), the apex court held that:
- Pure Common Law Passing Off: Where a claimant sues strictly to protect an unregistered trademark, trade name, or unregistered business get-up, the claim is rooted in common law tort. The Federal High Court lacks jurisdiction, and the action must be filed in the appropriate State High Court.
- Infringement Combined with Passing Off: The Federal High Court maintains exclusive jurisdiction only where the passing off claim is joined with an action for the infringement of a trademark duly registered under the Trade Marks Act.
- Registered Trademark Prerequisite: Without registration under the Trade Marks Act at the Commercial Law Department of the Federal Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment, the Federal High Court cannot adjudicate a standalone claim of passing off.
Business Name Registration versus Trademark Registration
A widespread misconception among Nigerian business owners is that registering a business name with the Corporate Affairs Commission automatically confers proprietary intellectual property protection over the brand name. Corporate Affairs Commission registration merely regularizes commercial trading identity and complies with statutory business registration obligations under CAMA 2020.
The differences between CAC registration and trademark protection are fundamental:
- Scope of Protection: A CAC business name registration prevents another entity from incorporating an identical or confusingly similar corporate name at the commission. It does not grant proprietary ownership of a commercial mark, brand symbol, or product design.
- Governing Legislation: Business names are regulated by CAMA 2020 under the Corporate Affairs Commission, whereas trademarks are governed by the Trade Marks Act under the Trademarks, Patents and Designs Registry.
- Legal Rights Conferred: Trademark registration confers an absolute statutory monopoly to use the mark in connection with specified classes of goods or services, enabling direct statutory infringement suits at the Federal High Court. Business name registration provides no statutory right of action under the Trade Marks Act.
Establishing the Elements of Passing Off in Nigerian Courts
When a business proprietor seeks redress in the State High Court for unlawful appropriation of their commercial reputation, the claimant must satisfy the classic trinity of passing off established in Reckitt & Colman Products Ltd v. Borden Inc:
- Establishment of Goodwill: The claimant must prove substantial commercial reputation and goodwill associated with the business name or visual get-up among consumers in the relevant geographical market.
- Actionable Misrepresentation: The claimant must demonstrate that the defendant employed deceptive names, logos, or packaging calculated to deceive the public into believing that the defendant goods or services originate from or are affiliated with the claimant.
- Demonstrable Damage or Likelihood of Damage: The claimant must establish actual financial loss, loss of prospective customers, or severe damage to commercial reputation arising from the defendant deceptive conduct.
Practical Litigation and Enforcement Recommendations
Before launching legal proceedings against a rival enterprise that is copying a business name or trading style, practitioners must carefully evaluate forum selection. Filing a standalone passing off suit in the Federal High Court without a registered trademark risks preliminary objections, protracted jurisdictional appeals, and potential striking out for want of jurisdiction.
Promoters and business proprietors should promptly register their brand identifiers, logos, and trading names as registered trademarks with the Trademarks Registry in Abuja. Once registered, the proprietor holds a dual shield: the statutory remedy of trademark infringement in the Federal High Court, and the common law remedy of passing off, securing total protection across both federal and state court jurisdictions.



