A registered trademark in Nigeria can be removed or cancelled from the Trade Marks Register if it has not been put to genuine commercial use for a continuous period of five years. Under Section 31 of the Trade Marks Act (Cap T13 LFN 2004), any aggrieved person has the statutory right to apply to the Registrar of Trade Marks or the Federal High Court to expunge an unused mark from the register.
Trademark protection in Nigeria grants a proprietor exclusive rights to a brand name, logo, or slogan. However, these rights are granted to facilitate active trade, not to allow businesses to hoard commercial names or prevent competitors from operating legitimately. Where a trademark proprietor abandons a mark or fails to introduce branded goods into Nigerian commerce, the law provides an avenue to clear the register.
Statutory Grounds for Cancellation Under Section 31
Section 31(1) of the Trade Marks Act establishes two separate grounds for striking an unused trademark off the register:
- Absence of Bona Fide Intention to Use: The applicant demonstrates that the trademark was registered without any bona fide intention on the part of the applicant to use it in connection with those goods, and that there has in fact been no bona fide use of the trade mark up to one month before the date of the application.
- Five Continuous Years of Non-Use: The applicant proves that a continuous period of five years or longer elapsed up to one month prior to the filing date during which the trademark was registered and remained entirely unused in Nigerian commerce in respect of the registered goods or classes.
Who Qualifies as a Person Aggrieved?
The Nigerian courts interpret the phrase person aggrieved broadly to prevent anti-competitive squatting on commercial registers. To maintain standing to seek trademark cancellation, an applicant must demonstrate a genuine commercial grievance.
A person aggrieved typically includes a competitor whose pending trademark application was rejected by the Trademarks Registry on grounds of conflict with the unused mark, or an enterprise facing legal threats of infringement from a trademark owner who conducts no active trade in Nigeria.
What Constitutes Genuine Bona Fide Commercial Use?
For a trademark owner to successfully defeat a non-use challenge, the use demonstrated must be genuine, commercial, and substantial. The courts and the Trademark Registrar scrutinize evidence according to practical standards:
- Actual Sales in Nigerian Markets: Submitting commercial invoices, customs import documents, bills of lading, and distribution contracts showing that products bearing the mark were physically traded in Nigeria.
- Meaningful Commercial Scale: Token or sham transactions arranged solely to maintain legal protection without a genuine market presence do not satisfy the statutory threshold of bona fide use.
- Direct Connection to Registered Goods: The trademark must be visibly applied to the specific classes of goods or packaging for which registration was originally granted.
Legal Defenses Against Trademark Cancellation
The Trade Marks Act provides specific statutory safe harbors that protect trademark owners who failed to trade due to factors beyond their commercial control.
Under Section 31(3) of the Act, an application for cancellation will fail if the proprietor proves that non-use was due to special circumstances in the trade rather than an intention to abandon the trademark:
- Statutory Import Restrictions: Complete bans on specific imported goods or government trade embargos that legally prevent the trademark owner from importing goods into Nigeria.
- Regulatory Approval Delays: Protracted regulatory certification procedures, such as waiting for mandatory product analysis and marketing approvals from NAFDAC or the Standards Organisation of Nigeria (SON), provided the owner took proactive steps to secure approvals.
- Foreign Exchange and Economic Directives: Documented foreign exchange rationing or central banking restrictions that temporarily paralyzed lawful import channels.
- Use of Associated Marks: Under Section 31(1) and Section 36 of the Act, the tribunal or court may accept the bona fide use of an associated registered mark, or the mark with minor modifications that do not affect its distinctiveness, as sufficient defense against cancellation.
Step-by-Step Procedure to Cancel an Unused Trademark
Initiating a cancellation proceeding requires systematic legal preparation and evidentiary verification:
- Market Due Diligence and Investigation: The applicant conducts market surveys, retail audits, and registry searches to confirm that goods bearing the registered mark have not appeared in Nigerian distribution channels for at least five continuous years.
- Selection of Forum: The applicant chooses whether to file the application directly before the Registrar of Trade Marks at the Commercial Law Department of the Federal Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment, or by Originating Motion at the Federal High Court.
- Filing the Application and Statement of Case: The applicant files the formal application accompanied by a statutory declaration setting out the facts, market search reports, and the specific grounds under Section 31.
- Service and Counter-Statement: The Registrar or Court serves the trademark proprietor, who has a statutory period (usually 30 days) to file a counter-statement and evidence of use or special circumstances.
- Hearing and Rectification Order: Following written addresses and arguments, the tribunal or judge determines whether continuous five-year non-use occurred without lawful justification. If proven, the court or Registrar issues an order rectifying the register, expunging the mark, and publishing the cancellation in the official Trade Marks Journal.