Minority shareholders in Nigeria can block an unfairly prejudicial transfer of a company business or undertaking by filing an application for relief against oppressive conduct under Sections 353 to 355 of CAMA 2020 or by initiating a derivative action under Sections 343 to 346. Furthermore, Section 342 of CAMA 2020 statutorily prohibits company directors from disposing of a substantial undertaking of the company without obtaining shareholder approval through a special resolution passed at a general meeting.
Historically, minority shareholders faced substantial obstacles under the common law rule in Foss v. Harbottle, which established that the company is the proper plaintiff for corporate wrongs and that majority rule prevails. CAMA 2020 fundamentally reshaped this dynamic by embedding robust statutory safeguards designed to prevent majority shareholders and colluding directors from stripping valuable corporate undertakings to the detriment of the minority.
The Statutory Veto Under Section 342 of CAMA 2020
Directors do not possess unchecked authority to sell or lease the operational foundation of a company. Section 342 of CAMA 2020 imposes a direct statutory restriction on the powers of directors regarding major asset transactions.
- Mandatory Shareholder Approval: The directors of a company shall not, without the prior approval of the company in a general meeting by special resolution, sell, lease, or otherwise dispose of the whole or a substantial part of the company undertaking or assets.
- Special Resolution Threshold: A special resolution requires a majority of not less than three-fourths (75 percent) of the votes cast by members entitled to vote in person or by proxy at a general meeting where at least 21 days written notice was issued.
- Definition of Substantial Undertaking: Any transaction involving the core operational assets, primary factory facilities, revenue-generating contracts, intellectual property portfolios, or branch networks that defines the commercial existence of the company.
If directors enter into an agreement to sell the undertaking without such a special resolution, the contract is ultra vires the directors powers, and any minority shareholder has direct legal standing to sue in their own name to restrain the illegal execution.
Unfairly Prejudicial Conduct Petitions Under Sections 353 to 355
Where the majority shareholders pass a special resolution to transfer the undertaking at an undervalue or to a related corporate vehicle owned by themselves, minority shareholders can invoke the unfair prejudice provisions under Section 353 and Section 354 of CAMA 2020.
An application may be brought by any member, regardless of their shareholding percentage, alleging that the affairs of the company are being conducted in an oppressive, unfairly discriminatory, or prejudicial manner. Upon hearing the petition, the Federal High Court possesses extensive remedial powers under Section 355, including:
- Granting an Injunction: Restraining the company, its directors, or prospective buyers from executing, registering, or completing the prejudicial transfer of the undertaking.
- Setting Aside Transactions: Declaring void and nullifying any completed transfer of assets executed in breach of statutory procedures or at an undervalue.
- Mandatory Share Buyout: Ordering the majority shareholders or the company itself to purchase the shares of the minority petitioning members at fair market value determined by an independent court-appointed valuation expert.
- Regulating Future Conduct: Formally altering the articles of association to introduce minority veto rights, board representation, or super-majority voting requirements on asset sales.
Commencing a Derivative Action Under Sections 343 to 346
When directors breach their fiduciary duty of loyalty under Section 305 by transferring corporate business to an entity in which they hold personal interests, the primary wrong is committed against the company. A minority shareholder can initiate a derivative action on behalf of the company under Section 343.
To bring a derivative action, the minority shareholder must first apply for leave of the Federal High Court under Section 344. The applicant must establish three statutory conditions:
- Reasonable Notice: The applicant must have given reasonable notice to the directors of intention to apply to the court if the directors fail to bring the action.
- Good Faith: The minority shareholder must be acting in good faith and not pursuing collateral personal vendettas.
- Best Interests of the Company: It must appear prima facie to be in the commercial interests of the company that the action be prosecuted.
Practical Immediate Steps to Block an Imminent Transfer
Minority shareholders facing an imminent asset stripping scheme should immediately issue a formal demand letter to the board warning of statutory breaches under Section 342. Simultaneously, file an ex parte motion for interim injunction at the Federal High Court to freeze the transaction status quo. Finally, lodge a formal caveat and dispute notification with the Corporate Affairs Commission to prevent the registration of asset charges, debentures, or altered corporate filings linked to the unauthorized transfer.