Challenging an ultra vires transfer of core corporate real estate assets executed by a receiver-manager under CAMA 2020 requires filing an urgent application before the Federal High Court to nullify the conveyance, set aside unlawful land registrations, and obtain injunctive relief restraining third-party purchasers from taking possession. Under Nigerian corporate insolvency law, while a receiver appointed under a debenture possesses statutory powers to realize charged assets, any sale executed outside the express scope of the debenture or in violation of statutory fiduciary duties is voidable and legally remediable.
Statutory Limits on Receiver Powers Under CAMA 2020
Under Section 552 and Section 556 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA 2020), the powers of a receiver or receiver-manager are strictly defined by the instrument creating the debenture charge and statutory provisions. A receiver appointed over specific charged assets (such as plant and machinery under a chattel mortgage) has no legal power to seize or convey uncharged corporate real estate titles.
Furthermore, under Section 555 of CAMA 2020, a receiver-manager stands in a fiduciary relationship to the company, its shareholders, and other creditors. The receiver is statutorily bound to act in utmost good faith and exercise the standard of care of a prudent businessman. Executing an undervalue fire-sale of prime commercial real estate to related entities or cronies of the secured lender constitutes bad faith, corporate waste, and an actionable breach of fiduciary duty.
Grounds for Nullifying Receiver Real Estate Disposals
Aggrieved directors, shareholders, and unsecured creditors have multiple robust grounds to challenge receiver transactions before the Federal High Court:
- Absence of Fixed Charge Over Real Estate: If the debenture created only a floating charge that failed to crystallize properly prior to alienation, or if the property was explicitly excluded from the debenture schedule, the receiver has no proprietary title to convey.
- Lack of Governor Consent Under the Land Use Act: Under Section 22 of the Land Use Act 1978, any alienation of statutory rights of occupancy requires the prior consent of the State Governor. A receiver deed of transfer executed without gubernatorial consent is void and inchoate under Nigerian land law.
- Gross Undervaluation and Collusive Sale: Under Section 555 of CAMA 2020, where a receiver sells corporate land at a gross undervalue without obtaining an independent valuation report from a registered estate surveyor, the transaction can be impeached for fraud on the power.
Procedural Pathway for Injunctive and Restitutionary Relief
To successfully challenge an unlawful real estate transfer, the company or interested shareholders must act methodically:
- Originating Summons Before the Federal High Court: Applicants file an originating summons seeking a declaration that the purported sale is ultra vires, null, and void, together with an order of perpetual injunction setting aside the deed of transfer.
- Urgent Motion for Interlocutory Injunction: Simultaneously, counsel must file an urgent application for an interlocutory injunction to restrain the receiver and the purported purchaser from entering into possession, altering the physical structures, or transferring title to third parties.
- Registration of Lis Pendens at State Land Registry: A formal notice of pending litigation (lis pendens) must be registered against the property title at the State Land Registry to put prospective buyers on legal notice, preventing the purchaser from asserting bona fide purchaser for value without notice.
Personal Liability and Professional Disqualification of the Receiver
Under Section 555(3) of CAMA 2020, a receiver who acts in breach of his fiduciary duty or exceeds his statutory authority is personally liable to indemnify the company and any injured party for resulting financial losses. In addition, aggrieved parties can file disciplinary petitions before the Business Recovery and Insolvency Practitioners Association of Nigeria (BRIPAN) and report the receiver to the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) for professional misconduct.
Corporate Insolvency Reforms and Equitable Protection
The judicial approach to unauthorized receiver asset alienations reflects modern CAMA 2020 principles aimed at enterprise rescue. Where a receiver attempts to unilaterally sell headquarters or manufacturing sites without formal notification to unsecured creditors, Nigerian courts readily intervene to preserve productive enterprise assets, preventing predatory asset stripping that prejudices company rehabilitative potential.