An unlawful amendment to company articles aimed at entrenching existing directors can be challenged by instituting an action under Sections 53, 288, and 353 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 before the Federal High Court. Any minority shareholder or aggrieved member can apply to nullify article alterations that conflict with mandatory statutory removal rights, infringe fundamental shareholder protections, or constitute an unfair prejudice or fraud on the minority.
The Inviolability of Section 288 and Statutory Removal Rights
Under Nigerian company law, the power of members to remove a director is an inalienable statutory right. Section 288 of CAMA 2020 explicitly provides that a company may by ordinary resolution remove a director before the expiration of their period of office, notwithstanding anything in its articles or in any agreement between the company and the director.
Any amendment to articles of association that attempts to make a directorship permanent, creates super-weighted voting rights designed solely to defeat an ordinary resolution, or imposes impossible procedural hurdles on director removal violates Section 288. Nigerian courts consistently hold that article clauses attempting to extinguish statutory removal mechanisms are ultra vires, null, and void.
Statutory Application to Cancel Alterations Under Section 53
CAMA 2020 provides a direct statutory challenge mechanism for qualifying shareholders who object to an altered article:
- Standing to Apply: Under Section 53 of CAMA 2020, an application to cancel an alteration to the articles may be made to the Federal High Court by holders of not less in the aggregate than 15 percent in nominal value of the company’s issued share capital or any class of shares.
- Statutory Limitation Period: The application must be filed within 28 days after the date on which the special resolution altering the articles was passed at the general meeting.
- Suspension of CAC Filing: Once an application is properly instituted and served on the company, the altered articles cannot take legal effect, and the Corporate Affairs Commission cannot register the alteration until the court determines the suit.
- Judicial Powers: The Federal High Court may confirm the alteration in whole or in part, or cancel the alteration entirely if it finds the amendment oppressive or procedurally invalid.
Challenging Through Unfair Prejudice Petitions Under Section 353 and 354
Where minority shareholders do not meet the 15 percent capital threshold under Section 53, they can invoke Section 353 of CAMA 2020 by filing an unfair prejudice petition. A member may petition the Federal High Court on the ground that the affairs of the company are being conducted in a manner that is oppressive, unfairly discriminatory, or unfairly prejudicial to one or more members.
Entrenching incumbent directors through manipulative corporate restructuring constitutes classic oppressive conduct under Section 354. In such petitions, the court exercises expansive remedial powers, including:
- Directing or prohibiting any act, including setting aside the entrenching resolution.
- Ordering the rectification of the company’s register and regulatory filings at the Corporate Affairs Commission.
- Appointing an independent director or interim management committee to stabilize company operations.
- Directing the company or majority shareholders to purchase the shares of the aggrieved minority at fair market valuation.
Exceptions to the Rule in Foss v. Harbottle Under Section 343
The common-law rule in Foss v. Harbottle traditionally prevented individual shareholders from suing for wrongs committed against the company. However, Section 343 of CAMA 2020 codifies explicit exceptions, granting individual members personal standing to bring injunctive and declaratory suits where:
- The act complained of is illegal or ultra vires the company’s constitution.
- The matter could only be done validly by a special resolution and was passed by an inadequate majority or fraudulent procedure.
- The act infringes the personal and individual rights of the member, such as voting and participation rights.
- The directors and majority shareholders have perpetrated a fraud on the minority, exploiting corporate machinery to monopolize management control.
Practical Steps and Restraining CAC Registration
Counsel representing aggrieved shareholders must act swiftly upon learning of the entrenching resolution. In addition to filing the substantive petition at the Federal High Court, counsel must serve formal notice of lis pendens and an interim injunctive order on the Corporate Affairs Commission.
Upon receipt of court processes, the CAC is bound by administrative law and Section 53 to freeze registration of the disputed Form CAC 7 and amended articles. This prompt intervention preserves the existing governance status quo and prevents entrenched directors from executing irreversible commercial commitments.