An unlawful cancellation of founder shares under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020 is challenged by filing a petition before the Federal High Court alleging unfairly prejudicial conduct under Section 353 and Section 354, or an originating summons seeking a declaration that the purported cancellation is ultra vires, null, and void. Because CAMA 2020 strictly prohibits the arbitrary cancellation or reduction of issued shares without shareholder special resolutions, class consent, and Federal High Court confirmation under Section 131, any unilateral board forfeiture or cancellation can be overturned with orders rectifying the register of members.
Statutory Protection of Issued Share Capital Under CAMA 2020
Under CAMA 2020, shares once allotted and issued to a founder become personal property under Section 138, entitling the owner to full proprietary and voting protections. The board of directors possesses no inherent power to cancel, dilute away, or confiscate issued shares simply because of an internal dispute, employment termination, or disagreements between co-founders.
While Section 124 of CAMA 2020 eliminated the former concept of authorized share capital requiring companies to have only issued share capital, it strictly preserved capital maintenance principles. Issued shares cannot be extinguished except through formal capital reduction procedures confirmed by the Federal High Court under Section 131, or lawful forfeiture strictly based on failure to pay calls pursuant to explicit company articles.
Grounds for Declaring Share Cancellation Null and Void
To successfully set aside a cancellation in court, the affected founder can establish several statutory breaches:
- Absence of a Special Resolution: Section 131 mandates a special resolution passed by seventy-five percent of voting shareholders before any capital reduction can occur.
- Failure to Secure Federal High Court Sanction: Any reduction in issued shares that extinguishes or cancels shares without an order of confirmation from the Federal High Court is void ab initio.
- Violation of Class Rights: If the founder shares carry special voting rights, anti-dilution rights, or preferential rights, Section 141 requires the separate written consent of three-quarters of the holders of that class.
- Breach of Natural Justice and Pre-emption Provisions: Canceling shares without proper contractual notice or statutory call mechanisms violates fundamental statutory procedure.
Procedural Avenues for Judicial Redress
The aggrieved founder has multiple procedural options before the Federal High Court, which holds exclusive jurisdiction over corporate matters under Section 251(1)(e) of the 1999 Constitution:
- Unfair Prejudice Petition Under Section 353 to 355: The founder files a petition asserting that the affairs of the company are being conducted in a manner that is oppressive, unfairly discriminatory, or unfairly prejudicial to their interests as a member.
- Action for Rectification of the Register Under Section 115: Where the company unlawfully strikes the founder name from the register of members or alters their shareholding balance, the founder applies for an order directing immediate rectification and reinstatement.
- Originating Summons for Declaratory Relief: The founder seeks judicial declarations that board resolutions purporting to cancel the founder equity are ultra vires the directors powers and invalid.
- Interlocutory Injunction: An urgent motion seeking to restrain the company, directors, and the CAC from registering any new share structure or issuing shares to third parties pending the final determination of the substantive lawsuit.
Remedies the Federal High Court Can Grant Under Section 355
The remedial powers of the Federal High Court under Section 355 of CAMA 2020 are exceptionally broad:
- Directing the immediate cancellation of the fraudulent board resolution and restoring the founder original shareholding on the CAC portal.
- Restraining the company from holding meetings or passing resolutions without the founder participation.
- Ordering an independent forensic audit and valuation of the company shares.
- Directing the majority shareholders or the company to buy out the founder shares at a fair market value determined by an independent court-appointed expert.
- Awarding substantial damages and legal costs against the errant directors personally for breach of fiduciary duties under Section 305 of CAMA 2020.
Administrative Notice and Caveat at the CAC
Concurrently with court proceedings, the founder legal counsel should file a formal letter of protest and caveat with the Registrar-General of the Corporate Affairs Commission. This notice places CAC on notice that the shareholding is subject to pending judicial determination, preventing the registration of fraudulent filings or altered status reports.