To challenge an unlawful cancellation or withholding of redeemable preference share coupons by corporate directors in Nigeria, aggrieved preference shareholders must file a petition against unfair prejudice and oppressive conduct under Sections 353 and 354 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, or institute an action for breach of class rights and contract under Section 167 in the Federal High Court. Corporate directors do not possess statutory or unilateral powers to void, reduce, or cancel contractually guaranteed preference dividends without complying with the terms of share issuance, class variation rules, and company articles.
Redeemable preference shares constitute a hybrid investment instrument that combines equity ownership with strict contractual dividend entitlements. When directors attempt to preserve corporate cash or favor common equity shareholders by suppressing preference coupons, the law provides robust shareholder protections.
Statutory Rights of Preference Shareholders Under CAMA 2020
The issuance, dividend rights, and redemption parameters of preference shares are regulated under multiple provisions of CAMA 2020:
- Class Rights Protection Under Section 146: When a company creates distinct share classes, the rights attached to redeemable preference shares (including coupon rate, cumulative dividend rights, and priority in capital return) form part of the corporate constitution.
- Redemption Conditions Under Section 182: Preference shares can only be redeemed out of distributable profits of the company or out of the proceeds of a fresh issue of shares made for the purposes of the redemption.
- Restrictions on Class Right Variations Under Section 166: Directors cannot alter or abrogate the dividend rights of preference shareholders unless the alteration is sanctioned by a separate class meeting with a special resolution passed by at least three-quarters of that class.
- Directors’ Fiduciary Duties Under Section 305: Directors must exercise their powers in good faith, in the best interest of the company as a whole, and not for collateral purposes that unfairly prejudice one class of members for the benefit of ordinary shareholders.
Available Judicial Remedies in the Federal High Court
Where directors unlawfully cancel or suspend coupon payments, preference shareholders can apply to the Federal High Court for decisive statutory relief:
- Application to Cancel Class Variations: Under Section 167 of CAMA 2020, the holders of not less in the aggregate than 15 percent of the issued shares of that class can apply to the court within 21 days of any purported variation to have the resolution declared void and unenforceable.
- Oppression Petition Under Section 353: Shareholders can file an originating petition demonstrating that the directors’ cancellation of coupons is oppressive, unfairly discriminatory, or unfairly prejudicial to their class.
- Injunction Against Common Dividends: The court can grant an interim injunction restraining the company and directors from declaring, approving, or distributing any dividends to ordinary shareholders until the accrued preference coupons are settled in full.
- Compulsory Redemption or Buy-Back Order: Under Section 355 of CAMA 2020, the court possesses broad discretionary powers to order the company or majority shareholders to purchase the petitioners’ preference shares at an independent fair valuation.
Procedural Steps for Aggrieved Shareholders
A preference shareholder or syndicate seeking to enforce coupon payment must follow a structured legal sequence:
- Step 1: Document Review and Financial Inspection: Scrutinize the company’s Articles of Association, the original Share Subscription Agreement, and recent audited financial statements to confirm whether the shares are cumulative and whether the company generated distributable reserves.
- Step 2: Formal Pre-Action Demand: Serve a formal legal demand letter on the board of directors, calling attention to the contractual coupon provisions and the statutory illegality of any unilateral coupon cancellation.
- Step 3: Mobilizing the Statutory Quota: If challenging a formal board resolution under Section 167, coordinate with fellow preference holders to consolidate at least 15 percent of the class holding within the strict 21-day limitation period.
- Step 4: Commencing Federal High Court Proceedings: File an Originating Process supported by an affidavit verifying the share certificates, proof of unpaid dividend declarations, and legal arguments establishing oppressive board conduct.
CAC Regulatory Filings and Corporate Governance Penalties
Enforcement extends beyond private litigation into statutory regulatory reporting:
Where the Federal High Court delivers judgment setting aside an unlawful coupon cancellation or ordering share redemption, the company secretary must file an office copy of the judgment with the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) within fifteen days. Failure to notify the CAC is an offense punishable by continuous statutory daily default fines against every responsible director and officer under CAMA 2020.



