To challenge an unlawful reduction of issued share capital by corporate directors under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, aggrieved shareholders or creditors must file an action by Originating Summons or an oppression petition before the Federal High Court under Sections 130 through 134 and Section 353 of the Act. Directors possess no legal power to unilaterally cancel, extinguish, or alter issued shares without passing a special resolution at a general meeting, securing formal confirmation from the Federal High Court, and registering the court order with the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC).
The principle of capital maintenance is a bedrock concept in Nigerian corporate law designed to protect creditors and minority shareholders. Share capital serves as a permanent financial buffer against corporate insolvency, meaning any unauthorized reduction constitutes an illegal, ultra vires act that is void ab initio.
Statutory Rules Governing Lawful Capital Reduction Under CAMA 2020
Under Section 130 of CAMA 2020, a company limited by shares may reduce its issued share capital only if all of the following conditions are strictly fulfilled:
- Articles of Association Authorization: The company articles of association must contain express authorization enabling capital reduction. If absent, the articles must first be amended by special resolution.
- Special Resolution of Shareholders: The company must pass a special resolution approved by at least 75 percent of voting members present at an extraordinary general meeting (EGM) or annual general meeting (AGM).
- Confirmation by the Federal High Court: Under Section 131, the company must apply to the Federal High Court by petition for an order confirming the reduction. The court will not grant the order unless satisfied that every creditor entitled to object has either consented or had their debt secured or discharged under Section 132.
- Registration with the CAC: Under Section 134, the court order and a statutory minute approved by the court showing the revised share capital structure must be delivered to the CAC. The reduction takes legal effect only upon formal registration by the Commission.
Common Forms of Unlawful Capital Reduction by Directors
Directors frequently attempt unlawful capital reductions through indirect or disguised mechanisms, all of which remain actionable in court:
- Unilateral Share Cancellations: Executive directors purporting to cancel or void share certificates held by contentious minority shareholders under the pretext of administrative irregularities.
- Disguised Capital Returns: Returning capital to select majority shareholders through sham management fees, unsecured loans, or fictitious corporate asset transfers.
- Non-Compliant Share Buybacks: Purchasing company shares without complying with the strict statutory solvency statement, shareholder authorization, and capital preservation thresholds mandated under Sections 184 to 187 of CAMA 2020.
- Selective Share Forfeitures: Forfeiting shares for alleged non-payment of calls without serving mandatory statutory warning notices or complying with procedural rules in the company articles.
Step-by-Step Procedure to Challenge an Illegal Reduction
Aggrieved shareholders or creditors must act decisively through the following sequential legal steps:
- Conduct an Official CAC Search: Perform an immediate search on the CAC Company Registration Portal (CRP) to inspect the company status report, current register of members, and any recent filings or special resolutions submitted by the board.
- Issue a Formal Legal Demand: Instruct a corporate lawyer to serve a formal cease-and-desist letter on the board, notifying directors that their actions violate Section 130 of CAMA 2020 and demanding immediate restoration of the issued share capital.
- File a Petition or Originating Summons in the Federal High Court: Institute proceedings seeking declarations that the purported reduction is ultra vires, null, and void. If the reduction unfairly targets minority investors, frame the petition under Section 353 and Section 354 for relief against unfairly prejudicial, oppressive, or discriminatory conduct.
- Apply for an Immediate Interlocutory Injunction: File an urgent motion for an interlocutory injunction restraining the directors from implementing the reduction, holding EGMs based on altered share registers, or paying out dividends based on modified shareholdings.
- Notify and Join the Corporate Affairs Commission: Put the CAC on formal notice of the pending litigation or join the Commission as a nominal party to prevent the electronic processing and registration of any unlawful corporate returns.
- Pray for Rectification of the Register: Under Section 115 of CAMA 2020, pray the Federal High Court for an order directing the rectification of the company register of members and company records to reflect the true, unreduced shareholding.
Statutory Remedies Granted by the Federal High Court
The Federal High Court possesses wide equitable and statutory powers under Section 354 of CAMA 2020. When an unlawful capital reduction is proven, the court can issue orders declaring the board resolution null and void, ordering full restitution of corporate funds disbursed to majority shareholders, restraining directors from further interference, and awarding substantial legal costs.
In extreme cases of persistent board bad faith, the court may order the compulsory purchase of the petitioner shares at fair market value or appoint a court-supervised administrator to manage company affairs until corporate governance integrity is restored.