Challenging an unlawful selective allotment of shares designed to dilute minority equity under CAMA 2020 requires filing an originating summons and petition before the Federal High Court under Section 142, Section 353, and Section 354 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act. Under Nigerian corporate law, directors cannot exercise their statutory share allotment powers for the collateral purpose of entrenching their control, altering voting majorities, or expropriating minority equity without strictly complying with statutory pre-emptive rights and judicial fairness standards.
Statutory Pre-Emptive Rights Under Section 142 of CAMA 2020
A central innovation of CAMA 2020 is the strict codification of statutory pre-emptive rights for all private and public companies. Under Section 142(1) of CAMA 2020, a company cannot issue or allot new shares unless they are offered in the first instance to all existing shareholders in proportion to their existing shareholdings, as nearly as circumstances permit. Controlling directors frequently attempt to bypass pre-emptive rights by issuing shares to friendly third parties or allied corporate vehicles under the guise of an urgent equity capital raise.
Any selective share allotment executed without first making a proportional rights offer to all existing shareholders violates Section 142, rendering the purported allotment voidable, ultra vires, and liable to be set aside by the court. Furthermore, under Section 142(2), existing shareholders must be given a reasonable statutory period (not less than 21 days) to accept or reject the pre-emptive offer before shares can be offered to outside parties.
Improper Purpose Doctrine and Fiduciary Breaches Under Section 305
Under Section 279 and Section 305 of CAMA 2020, directors stand in a fiduciary relationship to the company and must exercise their powers exclusively for proper corporate purposes. The established common law proper purpose doctrine (as applied in Nigerian courts) dictates that the power to issue shares is granted to directors primarily to raise bona fide capital for corporate expansion. Using share allotment powers to dilute an activist minority shareholder or swing control ahead of a contentious annual general meeting constitutes an abuse of fiduciary power.
Even if an allotment is nominally permitted by corporate articles, exercising that power for the improper purpose of manipulating shareholder voting balances constitutes bad faith and an act of misfeasance, entitling injured shareholders to judicial restitution.
Procedural Pathway for Resisting Dilution and Setting Aside Allotments
To successfully challenge an oppressive share dilution, minority shareholders must follow established litigation steps:
- Originating Summons Before the Federal High Court: Applicants file an originating summons seeking a declaratory judgment that the purported allotment violates Section 142 of CAMA 2020, together with an order of perpetual injunction setting aside the allotment and rectifying the company register of members.
- Urgent Motion for Interlocutory Injunction: Simultaneously, counsel must file an urgent application for an interlocutory injunction restraining the company, directors, and the allottee from exercising any voting rights attached to the disputed shares or paying dividends on them pending trial.
- Minority Oppression Petition Under Section 353 and 354: Dissenting shareholders file an alternative petition alleging that the affairs of the company are being conducted in an unfairly prejudicial and oppressive manner.
Judicial Rectification and CAC Regulatory Injunctions
Under Section 115 and Section 354(2) of CAMA 2020, the Federal High Court possesses extensive remedial authority to order the complete rectification of the register of members at the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC). Filing a notice of lis pendens and court objection processes with the CAC prevents the Commission from registering Form CAC 2A (Return of Allotment) pending final judgment.
The court may also make an order regulating the future conduct of company affairs, directing the controlling majority to purchase the minority equity at fair market value determined by an independent court-appointed auditor, or restraining any further share issuances without unanimous shareholder consent.
Personal Fiduciary Liability and Recovery of Dilution Damages
Directors who willfully orchestrate unlawful share allotments face personal civil liability under Section 305 of CAMA 2020. Aggrieved shareholders can hold delinquent board members jointly and severally liable to indemnify the company and injured investors for all valuation losses, legal expenses, and transactional costs incurred in setting aside the unlawful dilution scheme.