An aggrieved party enforces a share buyback agreement under the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 by verifying strict adherence to statutory authorization under Sections 184 to 187, establishing that the transaction satisfied the mandatory solvency test, and instituting an action at the Federal High Court for specific performance, damages, or debt recovery. Nigerian corporate law prohibits companies from purchasing their own shares unless every substantive and procedural requirement enacted by CAMA 2020 is met.
The Legal Framework Governing Share Buybacks Under CAMA 2020
Prior to the enactment of CAMA 2020, Nigerian company law strictly maintained the common law rule established in Trevor v Whitworth, which prohibited a company from buying back its own shares to protect corporate capital for creditors. Section 184 of CAMA 2020 introduced a significant shift by permitting companies to acquire their own shares, provided specific statutory thresholds are met.
To successfully enforce a share buyback contract against a company, the claimant must prove that the transaction complied with the following non-negotiable statutory conditions:
- Articles of Association Authorization: The company articles of association must contain express provisions authorizing the company to buy back its own shares under Section 184(1).
- Shareholder Approval via Special Resolution: The purchase agreement must be sanctioned by a special resolution passed by shareholders at a general meeting, requiring at least a 75 percent majority of votes cast.
- Distributable Profits Rule: Under Section 185, shares must be purchased out of distributable profits of the company or from proceeds of a fresh issue of shares made specifically for the buyback. Capital reserves cannot be depleted.
- Quantitative Limitation: A company cannot acquire its own shares if the acquisition would result in the company holding more than 15 percent of the total nominal value of its issued share capital.
The Mandatory Solvency Test Under Section 185
A share buyback agreement cannot be enforced against a company if performing the transaction would push the company into insolvency. CAMA 2020 prioritizes creditor protection over shareholder exit agreements.
The solvency test requires directors to execute a statutory declaration affirming two core elements:
- Ability to Pay Debts: There are no grounds on which the company could be found unable to pay its debts as they fall due in the ordinary course of business during the 12 months immediately following the buyback date.
- Asset Over Liability Surplus: The total value of the company assets exceeds the sum of its total liabilities, including contingent and prospective liabilities.
If performing the buyback agreement would render the company unable to pay its trade debts or service commercial obligations, the Federal High Court will refuse an order of specific performance, because enforcing an illegal transaction violates public policy.
Judicial Enforcement Mechanisms at the Federal High Court
The Federal High Court holds exclusive jurisdiction over corporate and CAMA matters under Section 251(1)(e) of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria. An aggrieved shareholder or investor seeking to compel performance or recover purchase consideration must pursue specific legal channels:
- Action for Specific Performance: Where the company executed a binding buyback agreement, satisfied all CAMA 2020 conditions, passed the special resolution, and remains solvent, the seller can file an action demanding an order compelling the company to execute the share transfer and remit payment.
- Action for Liquidated Debt: Where the company already accepted the share certificates and executed transfer instruments but withheld the agreed purchase consideration, the shareholder can institute summary judgment proceedings under the Federal High Court Civil Procedure Rules for a liquidated debt claim.
- Petition for Relief from Unfairly Prejudicial Conduct: Where controlling directors deliberately manipulate buyback procedures to disenfranchise minority investors, the aggrieved shareholder can petition under Section 354 of CAMA 2020 for relief against oppressive conduct.
- Damages for Breach of Contract: In circumstances where the buyback cannot be specifically enforced due to changed capital structures, the claimant may claim general and special damages against the company.
Personal Liability of Directors in Unauthorized Buybacks
Directors who approve or execute a share buyback agreement without satisfying the statutory solvency test face severe personal exposure under Section 186 of CAMA 2020:
- Joint and Several Liability: Directors who knowingly sign a false solvency declaration or sanction an unlawful buyback are jointly and severally liable to restore the depleted funds to the company.
- Criminal Sanctions: Making a false solvency declaration without reasonable grounds constitutes a criminal offense punishable by fines and potential imprisonment under Nigerian law.
- Indemnification Bar: The company cannot indemnify directors for liabilities incurred through fraudulent or negligent buyback arrangements.
Practical Checklist Before Initiating Enforcement Proceedings
Legal practitioners representing claimants in share buyback disputes must gather conclusive documentary evidence before approaching the court:
- Certified True Copy of the company Articles of Association confirming buyback power.
- Certified True Copy of the Special Resolution filed at the CAC.
- The written Share Purchase Agreement signed by authorized company representatives with corporate seal affixed.
- Latest audited financial statements of the company demonstrating solvency.
- Formal letter of demand served on the registered office of the company giving statutory notice.



