Enforcing a shareholder derivative claim under Section 343 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020 requires instituting an action before the Federal High Court in the name or on behalf of the company, but only after first obtaining prior leave of court. Because a company possesses separate legal personality, any wrong committed against the company must ordinarily be redressed by the company itself. Section 343 creates a codified statutory exception to the common law rule in Foss v Harbottle, enabling eligible stakeholders to enforce corporate rights when wrongdoing directors or majority shareholders refuse to act.
Under Section 343 of CAMA 2020, an applicant can seek leave of court to bring an action in the name of the company or any of its subsidiaries, or intervene in an existing action to which the company is a party, to prosecute, defend, or discontinue the litigation on behalf of the corporate body.
Standing to apply for leave is broad under Section 344 of CAMA 2020. The statute extends locus standi beyond registered legal members to include several key categories of applicants:
- Registered shareholders: Any person holding shares in the company entered into the register of members.
- Beneficial owners: Any person who has beneficial ownership of shares, even if legal title remains with a nominee or trustee.
- Present or past officers: Current or former directors and officers of the company or its subsidiaries.
- Discretionary applicants: Any other person who, in the discretion of the Federal High Court, is deemed a proper person to make an application under Section 344.
To secure judicial leave to proceed with a derivative action, the applicant must satisfy three mandatory statutory threshold tests set out in Section 344(2) of CAMA 2020:
- Pre-action Notice to the Board: The applicant must prove that reasonable notice was served on the directors of the company, demanding that they cause the company to institute, prosecute, defend, or discontinue the action, and the directors failed or refused to do so within a reasonable time.
- Good Faith of the Applicant: The applicant must demonstrate that the application is brought in absolute good faith and not to pursue a personal vendetta, extortion, or collateral commercial advantage against co-investors.
- Best Interests of the Company: The applicant must establish that it is prima facie in the best interests of the company that the proceedings be brought, defended, or prosecuted.
The procedural mechanism for obtaining leave involves filing an Originating Summons or Motion on Notice before the Federal High Court in the judicial division where the registered office or principal place of business of the company is located. The application must be supported by a detailed affidavit with concrete documentary exhibits. These exhibits typically include the written demand letter served on the board of directors, proof of service, corporate filings showing shareholding or directorship status, evidence of the alleged breach of fiduciary duty or misappropriation of assets, and the proposed substantive statement of claim.
Once the Federal High Court grants leave, the action proceeds in the name of the company, but the conduct of the case remains under the direct supervision of the court. Under Section 345 of CAMA 2020, the court exercises extensive powers to protect the integrity of the litigation:
- Control of Litigation: The court may give directions concerning the conduct of the action, including determining which legal counsel represents the company and who controls procedural decisions.
- Interim Legal Costs and Indemnity: Recognizing that minority shareholders often lack resources to litigate against entrenched directors, Section 345(2) empowers the court to order the company to pay the applicant reasonable interim legal fees and disbursements incurred in prosecuting the claim.
- Restriction on Settlements: No derivative action brought under CAMA 2020 can be settled, compromised, or discontinued without formal leave and approval of the Federal High Court, ensuring that collusive settlements between parties are strictly prevented.
- Destination of Judgment Proceeds: Any monetary damages, restitution, or assets recovered through the judgment are paid directly into the corporate treasury of the company, rather than to the individual applicant shareholder.
Litigants should distinguish derivative claims under Section 343 from personal or representative actions brought under Section 346, or petitions for relief against unfairly prejudicial and oppressive conduct under Section 353 of CAMA 2020. A derivative claim is designed exclusively to remedy a wrong done to the company, making compliance with the statutory leave procedure indispensable before the Federal High Court can assume jurisdiction.