To challenge an unlawful buy-back of preference shares under CAMA 2020, you file an action in the Federal High Court, which has exclusive jurisdiction over company law matters in Nigeria by virtue of Section 251 of the 1999 Constitution (as amended). The action can be brought by any aggrieved shareholder, preference shareholder, or the company itself, depending on who suffered the harm and what relief is being sought.
CAMA 2020 introduced detailed rules on share buy-backs in Sections 184 to 186. A company is permitted to purchase its own shares, including preference shares, but only in strict compliance with the conditions set out in those sections. Any buy-back that does not comply with these conditions is unlawful and can be challenged in court.
Statutory Conditions for a Lawful Buy-Back Under CAMA 2020
The statutory conditions for a lawful preference share buy-back under CAMA 2020 include: the company’s articles of association must authorise the purchase of own shares; the shares must be fully paid before they are redeemed or purchased; the buy-back must be funded from distributable profits or from the proceeds of a fresh issue of shares made for the purpose of the buy-back; the nominal value of shares purchased must not exceed the limits permitted under the Act; and the terms and manner of the buy-back must be approved by an ordinary resolution of the company in general meeting unless the articles provide otherwise. A buy-back that violates any of these requirements is void or voidable.
Documents to Gather Before Filing
Before filing a lawsuit, gather all relevant documents. These should include the company’s memorandum and articles of association to check whether buy-back authority exists and on what terms; the board minutes and general meeting minutes approving the buy-back; the financial statements for the relevant period to assess whether distributable profits existed at the time of the buy-back; copies of the preference share certificates and any redemption notices served on preference shareholders; and correspondence from the company explaining the basis for the buy-back.
How to File the Lawsuit
The proper procedure for filing the lawsuit is as follows. First, instruct a solicitor to draft an originating summons or writ of summons depending on whether the facts are substantially agreed and the issues are primarily legal, or whether there are serious factual disputes requiring a full trial. Company law suits challenging a buy-back typically use an originating summons seeking declaratory and injunctive relief. The summons is filed at the Federal High Court in the judicial division where the company has its registered office or principal place of business.
Reliefs Available to the Court
Reliefs you can seek in the action include: a declaration that the buy-back was unlawful and void under CAMA 2020; an order restoring the preference shares to the register of members; an order setting aside any cancellation of the shares in the company’s register; an injunction restraining the company from distributing the consideration paid in the buy-back to any other party; a personal order against the directors who authorised and executed the unlawful buy-back to repay the funds to the company; and damages or compensation where the unlawful buy-back caused the plaintiff demonstrable financial loss.
Director Liability
Director liability is an important aspect of this action. Under Section 185 of CAMA 2020, where a company purports to purchase its own shares in contravention of the Act, every officer of the company who is in default is guilty of an offence and liable on conviction to a fine. Beyond the criminal offence, a director who authorised an unlawful buy-back can be sued personally for breach of fiduciary duty under Sections 305 and 306 of CAMA 2020. If the unlawful buy-back caused loss to the company, a derivative action can be brought by shareholders on behalf of the company against those directors.
Unfair Prejudice Petition
Where a preference shareholder was specifically targeted by an unlawful buy-back in a manner that is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or unfairly discriminatory, the shareholder can also bring a petition under Section 358 of CAMA 2020 for relief on grounds of unfair prejudice. The court hearing an unfair prejudice petition has wide remedial powers including ordering the company to buy back the shares of the petitioner at a fair price assessed by the court, ordering changes to the company’s constitution, and restraining the continuation of the conduct complained of.
Interlocutory Injunction
Where there is an immediate risk that the company will disperse the funds from the unlawful buy-back or cancel the share register entries before a hearing can be secured, the plaintiff should apply urgently for an interlocutory injunction and an order preserving the status quo pending the determination of the substantive suit. This application is typically made ex parte in the first instance and can be obtained quickly if strong evidence of the unlawful conduct is presented. Courts will grant this relief where the balance of convenience favours preservation of the position pending trial.
Why Timing Matters
Timing matters in these cases. Filing promptly after discovering the unlawful buy-back reduces the risk of limitation defences and increases the effectiveness of interim relief. Nigerian courts have upheld challenges to unlawful preference share buy-backs where the procedural requirements of CAMA were shown to have been ignored, and the companies and directors involved have faced both civil and regulatory consequences. Any preference shareholder who suspects their shares have been bought back in breach of CAMA 2020 should obtain legal advice immediately and preserve all relevant documentary evidence before initiating proceedings.