To challenge an unlawful buyback of shares under CAMA 2020, an aggrieved shareholder or creditor must institute an action before the Federal High Court seeking declaratory and injunctive reliefs to invalidate the transaction and compel the directors to refund company assets. The lawsuit is commenced pursuant to the minority protection provisions under Section 343 and unfair prejudice remedies under Sections 353 through 355 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, invoking the exclusive corporate jurisdiction conferred on the Federal High Court by Section 251(1)(e) of the 1999 Constitution.
While CAMA 2020 introduced a significant modernization by permitting companies to repurchase their own shares under Section 184, this power is hedged with strict procedural and financial guardrails designed to prevent capital depletion, insider self-dealing, and unlawful squeeze-outs of minority investors.
Statutory Preconditions for a Lawful Share Buyback Under CAMA 2020
Any challenge against a share repurchase begins by establishing that the company or its directors breached one or more mandatory conditions set out in Sections 184 to 190 of CAMA 2020:
- Articles Authorization: Under Section 184(1), the company Articles of Association must explicitly authorize the share repurchase. If the articles are silent, any buyback is ultra vires and void.
- Special Resolution Approval: Section 184(2) requires the buyback scheme to be approved by a special resolution of members passed at an extraordinary general meeting, requiring a 75 percent majority vote.
- Capital Solvency and Source of Funds: Repurchases can only be financed out of distributable profits or the proceeds of a fresh issue of shares made specifically for that purpose. A buyback cannot be financed from paid-up capital or in a manner that renders the company insolvent.
- Directors Statutory Declaration of Solvency: The board of directors must execute a formal statutory declaration confirming that the company will remain solvent and capable of paying its debts for at least twelve months following the transaction.
- Public Advertisement: The company must publish a notice of the proposed buyback in at least two national daily newspapers within fifteen days of passing the special resolution, alerting creditors and the investing public.
Determining Locus Standi and Grounds for Action
Under CAMA 2020, standing to challenge an improper share buyback belongs to specific affected stakeholders:
- Minority Shareholders: Shareholders who voted against the resolution or whose equity was unfairly diluted or expropriated can sue under Section 343 to restrain an illegal or ultra vires act, or petition under Section 354 on grounds that the corporate powers were exercised in a manner oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or unfairly discriminatory.
- Unsecured and Secured Creditors: Creditors whose financial security is threatened by the depletion of distributable reserves or disregard of the statutory solvency threshold possess locus standi to petition the court to set aside the transaction.
- Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC): The Commission may intervene directly or seek orders where a buyback contravenes statutory filings or conceals insolvency.
Procedure for Filing the Lawsuit Before the Federal High Court
The litigation process follows established judicial procedures under the Federal High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules:
- Selection of Originating Process: Where the challenge depends purely on statutory interpretation of CAMA 2020 and corporate meeting minutes, the lawsuit is commenced by Originating Summons. Where the suit alleges fraudulent valuation of shares, director kickbacks, or forged solvency statements, it must be initiated by Writ of Summons with detailed Pleadings.
- Motion on Notice for Interlocutory Injunction: Concurrently with the originating process, file an urgent interlocutory application to restrain the company, directors, and registrars from disbursing funds, cancelling share certificates, or altering the CAC Register of Members pending the trial.
- Evidentiary Documentation: Annex certified true copies of the company Memorandum and Articles of Association, minutes of the general meeting, the defective solvency declaration, audited financial statements proving insolvency, and bank transfer instructions.
- Service on Necessary Parties: Serve the court processes on the corporate defendant, the participating directors in their personal capacities, the selling shareholders who received unlawful consideration, and the Corporate Affairs Commission.
Judicial Remedies Available Under CAMA 2020
Upon proving statutory violations, the Federal High Court possesses wide remedial discretion under Section 355 of CAMA 2020 to grant comprehensive corrective orders:
- Order of Nullification: Declaring the special resolution, the share buyback agreement, and subsequent share transfers null, void, and of no legal effect.
- Personal Liability and Restitution: Under Section 187, directors who knowingly sign a false solvency statement or execute an unlawful capital return become jointly and severally liable to refund the full expenditure back into the company treasury.
- Rectification of the Register of Members: Directing the CAC and the company secretary to restore the names of original shareholders and reinstate their voting rights without penalty.
- Investigation of Corporate Affairs: Directing the CAC to appoint independent forensic inspectors to investigate systemic accounting irregularities or board malfeasance.
Challenging an unlawful share buyback in Nigeria requires swift legal action, thorough forensic accounting analysis, and precise statutory pleading to preserve corporate capital and protect investor equity from unlawful dilution.