Challenging an unlawful call on shares under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020 requires filing an originating summons or writ of summons at the Federal High Court seeking declaratory orders to nullify the call and an interlocutory injunction to restrain the forfeiture of the shares. The suit must establish that the directors acted ultra vires, violated the procedural requirements in the company Articles of Association, breached fiduciary duties under Section 305, or engaged in unfairly prejudicial conduct under Section 353 of CAMA 2020.
When an investor subscribes to partly paid shares in a Nigerian company, the directors hold discretionary authority to make calls for the remaining balance. However, this power is fiduciary in nature. Unscrupulous controlling shareholders and directors often manipulate calls on shares as an aggressive tactic to force minority shareholders into financial default, setting the stage for unlawful share forfeiture and hostile ownership dilution.
Substantive Grounds for Declaring a Call on Shares Unlawful
A shareholder seeking judicial intervention must establish clear legal defects in the call. Established grounds under Nigerian corporate jurisprudence include:
- Violation of Company Articles: The call failed to follow the exact procedure, timeframes, or payment intervals specified in the company Articles of Association.
- Defective Board Quorum or Resolution: The call was not authorized at a validly convened meeting of the board of directors with a lawful quorum, or was issued by individual executive directors acting without formal board delegation.
- Discriminatory or Unequal Treatment: The directors issued the call against specific minority shareholders while exempting themselves or allied shareholders holding the same class of partly paid shares.
- Improper Collateral Purpose: The directors made the call not to advance legitimate working capital requirements of the enterprise, but deliberately to oppress the claimant and engineer immediate share forfeiture.
- Deficient Statutory Notice: The company failed to provide the mandatory formal notice period, commonly fourteen or twenty-one days, explicitly stating the amount due, bank account details, and payment deadline.
Filing Procedure at the Federal High Court
Under Section 251(1)(e) of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, the Federal High Court possesses exclusive original jurisdiction over disputes concerning the operation, regulation, and management of companies incorporated under CAMA.
The aggrieved shareholder, acting through an accredited legal practitioner, initiates the lawsuit through the following structured litigation steps:
- Selection of Originating Process: File an Originating Summons where the dispute turns primarily on the interpretation of CAMA 2020 and the company registered Articles of Association without hostile factual conflicts. Where serious allegations of fraud, conspiracy, or contested corporate transactions are present, file a Writ of Summons accompanied by a Statement of Claim.
- Drafting the Affidavit in Support: Detail the history of share acquisition, payment receipts, correspondence received from the board, minutes of past meetings, and direct evidence of the procedural violations committed by the directors.
- Filing an Emergency Motion for Injunction: Simultaneously file a Motion on Notice and Motion Ex Parte seeking an immediate order of Interlocutory Injunction restraining the company and directors from enforcing the call, forfeiting the disputed shares, or altering the share register pending determination of the substantive suit.
- Joining Proper Parties: Cite the company as the primary defendant alongside the individual directors in their personal and corporate capacities. The Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) should be joined as a nominal defendant to ensure any resulting court order binds public regulatory records.
- Service of Court Processes: Effect formal service of the originating processes and motion on notice at the registered corporate office of the company and on the individual directors.
Available Reliefs Under CAMA 2020
The statement of claim or originating summons should seek robust declaratory and coercive remedies:
- A declaration that the resolution of the directors making the call on shares is irregular, oppressive, ultra vires, null, and void.
- A declaration that the notice of call issued to the plaintiff is invalid and unenforceable under the Articles of Association and CAMA 2020.
- An order of perpetual injunction restraining the defendants from demanding payment on the invalid call or taking steps toward share forfeiture.
- Statutory remedies against unfairly prejudicial and oppressive conduct pursuant to Section 353, Section 354, and Section 355 of CAMA 2020.
- An order under Section 115 for the rectification of the company Register of Members if the defendants have prematurely erased the claimant shareholding.
Litigants should act before the expiration of the notice period stated in the call. Once directors complete forfeiture and re-issue shares to third-party purchasers, legal recovery becomes considerably more complex and burdensome.