Challenging an unlawful compulsory acquisition of minority shares under CAMA 2020 requires instituting an action by Originating Summons or Originating Petition before the Federal High Court pursuant to Section 712, Section 715, and Section 353 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act. An aggrieved minority shareholder must apply to the court within the strict statutory period of one month from receiving the compulsory acquisition notice to obtain judicial orders halting the squeeze-out, invalidating the transaction, or directing an independent court-supervised revaluation of the shares.
Statutory Grounds for Challenging Squeeze-Out Transactions
Under Section 712 of CAMA 2020, where a takeover offer or acquisition scheme has been approved by holders of not less than ninety percent in value of the target shares, the acquirer may issue a statutory notice to squeeze out the remaining ten percent minority. However, the law prohibits arbitrary dispossession and sets strict substantive and procedural benchmarks.
Minority shareholders can challenge the compulsory acquisition on specific statutory grounds.
- Failure to Attain Legitimate Ninety Percent Approval: The acquiring entity cannot count shares already held by itself, its parent company, subsidiaries, or associated nominee entities to reach the ninety percent approval threshold. If the acquirer manipulated shareholdings through related corporate fronts, the statutory threshold was never lawfully achieved.
- Gross Undervaluation and Unfair Pricing: A compulsory squeeze-out must reflect fair market value. Where the acquisition price is depressed through skewed financial statements, suppressed book values, or manipulated trading prices on an over-the-counter platform, minority holders can establish commercial unfairness.
- Absence of Independent Valuation: CAMA 2020 mandates that valuations in corporate reorganizations and mergers must be supported by an independent valuation report from a registered financial analyst or chartered accountant. Omission of this report invalidates the squeeze-out notice.
- Oppressive and Unfairly Prejudicial Conduct: Under Section 353 and Section 354 of CAMA 2020, any act or proposed act of the company that unfairly discriminates against or oppresses a class of shareholders entitles the victim to seek court protection. Compelling shareholders to exit below market value constitutes statutory oppression.
Litigation Procedure in the Federal High Court
Litigation challenging compulsory acquisition moves rapidly because of rigid statutory deadlines.
- Action Within One Month: Section 712(2) of CAMA dictates that the dissenting shareholder must file their application within one calendar month of receipt of the formal notice of compulsory acquisition. Failure to file within this window extinguishes the statutory right to object, permitting the acquirer to pay the consideration to the company and take title to the shares.
- Filing of Originating Process: Initiate the lawsuit at the Federal High Court in the judicial division where the company maintains its registered corporate headquarters. File an Originating Summons or Petition accompanied by an affidavit of facts, copies of the scheme documents, statutory notices, and expert counter-valuation reports.
- Motion for Interlocutory Injunction: File an urgent motion for an interlocutory injunction restraining the company, its directors, and the share registrar from transferring, reallocating, cancelling, or registering the disputed minority shares pending trial.
- Service of Notice on the CAC: Serve a certified copy of the court processes on the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) where a public company is involved. This establishes notice of pending litigation (lis pendens) and prevents CAC registrars from updating the company share register.
Comparison Between Minority Squeeze-Out Remedies
Dissenting minority investors have multiple legal options depending on whether they wish to remain shareholders or exit at true market value.
- Order Halting Compulsory Acquisition: The court can order that the acquirer is not entitled to acquire the dissenting shares, leaving the minority shareholders in full possession of their equity.
- Court-Ordered Independent Valuation: The court can appoint an independent accounting or investment banking firm to determine the fair valuation of the shares and order the acquirer to pay that adjusted price.
- Section 354 Restitution Order: The court can order the target company or dominant directors to purchase the minority shares at a valuation determined by the court, with interest accrued from the acquisition date.
Final Judicial Remedies and Enforceability
Upon final hearing, if the Federal High Court finds that the compulsory acquisition violated CAMA 2020, it issues a binding judgment setting aside the acquisition notice. The judgment is served immediately on the Corporate Affairs Commission, which issues an administrative stop-order preventing any changes to the corporate registry file.
Any company or director that attempts to bypass court orders by altering the register of members commits contempt of court and faces committal proceedings under the Sheriffs and Civil Process Act. Dissenting shareholders are thus protected by judicial enforcement mechanisms from predatory corporate takeovers.