Filing a lawsuit to challenge an unlawful disposal of substantial property by directors under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020 requires commencing an originating process before the Federal High Court under Section 342, Section 343, or Section 346 of the Act. Under Section 342 of CAMA 2020, company directors lack the legal capacity to sell, lease, or otherwise dispose of the company’s undertaking or substantial property without the prior approval of members granted through an ordinary or special resolution passed at a general meeting.
The statutory restriction on major asset disposals represents a fundamental check on board overreach. When directors dispose of core operating equipment, industrial land, revenue-generating subsidiaries, or intellectual property portfolios without shareholder mandate, the transaction is ultra vires their managerial authority. Furthermore, where such transactions involve directors personally or their connected persons, Section 314 of CAMA 2020 imposes strict shareholder disclosure and approval requirements that cannot be circumvented through informal board consensus.
An aggrieved shareholder seeking judicial intervention must evaluate whether to proceed via a direct representative claim, a statutory derivative action, or a petition against oppressive conduct. Where directors have disposed of company property to enrich themselves or affiliated third parties, the company suffers the direct legal injury. Therefore, a derivative action brought under Section 346 of CAMA 2020 is typically the most potent procedural vehicle to recover the assets on behalf of the corporate entity.
Before launching a derivative action, the plaintiff must apply by motion on notice for leave of the Federal High Court. The court will grant leave if satisfied that the applicant has given reasonable notice to the directors of intention to sue, is acting in good faith, and that the prosecution of the action appears to be in the prima facie commercial interest of the company. Once leave is granted, the action proceeds in the name and on behalf of the company itself.
Simultaneously with the substantive action, the applicant must file an urgent application for an interlocutory injunction to prevent the buyer or third-party purchasers from taking possession, developing the land, or dissipating the disputed assets. Lis pendens notices should also be lodged with the relevant State Land Registry or the Corporate Affairs Commission to prevent any further encumbrances or transfers pending judgment.
Step-by-step litigation procedure to challenge unauthorized asset disposals:
- Issue a formal demand letter to the board of directors demanding the rescission of the unauthorized asset disposal agreement and immediate recovery of company property.
- Obtain certified true copies of the company’s CAC status report, Memorandum and Articles of Association, and relevant title documents from the land registry or asset registries.
- File an originating summons or writ of summons alongside a motion on notice for leave to institute a statutory derivative action under Section 346 of CAMA 2020.
- File an emergency motion for an interlocutory injunction restraining the directors and the purchasing third party from alienating, conveying, or dissipating the disputed property.
- Serve the originating processes, affidavits, and motion papers on all defendant directors, the recipient of the property, and the company’s registered office.
- Lodge formal notice of lis pendens at the State Land Registry and caveat notifications with the Corporate Affairs Commission.
- Argue the application for leave, demonstrating shareholder standing, directorial breach of fiduciary duty, and compliance with statutory notice conditions.
- Prosecute the substantive claim seeking judicial nullification of the sale, an order for asset restitution, and an order compelling defaulting directors to disgorge secret profits.
- Register the final enrolled court judgment with the CAC and land registries to restore unencumbered corporate title.
Comparison of procedural litigation paths under CAMA 2020:
- Derivative Action (Section 346): Brought in the company’s name to enforce corporate rights, recover diverted assets, and hold disloyal directors accountable for fiduciary breaches.
- Oppression Petition (Section 353): Brought by minority shareholders alleging that director actions are oppressive, unfairly discriminatory, or prejudicial, seeking court buy-out or restructuring orders.
- Representative Action (Section 343): Brought by shareholders in their personal capacity to enforce individual voting rights, preemptive entitlements, or statutory meeting participation.
- CAC Administrative Investigation (Section 315): Administrative petition inviting the Corporate Affairs Commission to appoint inspectors to investigate management fraud and asset dissipation.
Where the Federal High Court finds that directors unlawfully transferred company assets without required general meeting approval, Section 342 empowers the court to declare the transaction null and void against purchasers with notice. Defaulting directors remain personally liable to indemnify the company for any valuation deficits or legal expenses incurred in setting aside the unlawful alienation.