To challenge an unlawful disposal of a company undertaking by directors under CAMA 2020, an aggrieved shareholder must institute an action before the Federal High Court seeking declaratory reliefs, an injunction restraining the transaction, and an order rescinding the conveyance. Under Section 342(2) of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 (CAMA 2020), directors lack legal power to sell, lease, or dispose of the whole or a substantial part of the company undertaking or assets without prior authorization from shareholders at a general meeting.
The Statutory Prohibition Under Section 342(2)
While directors maintain broad general management powers under CAMA 2020, Section 342 imposes strict statutory limitations on their authority. Directors cannot enter into any transaction that transfers or surrenders the commercial lifeblood of the company without explicit member approval.
The term undertaking encompasses the operational enterprise, income-generating business divisions, core plant machinery, or real estate assets that constitute the primary commercial activity of the firm. A disposal of undertaking without a shareholder resolution is ultra vires the powers of the board and constitutes an illegal transaction under Nigerian corporate law.
Locus Standi: Who Can File the Suit?
Historically, the common law rule in Foss v. Harbottle restricted shareholders from suing for wrongs done to the company. However, CAMA 2020 provides clear statutory exceptions that confer standing on aggrieved members:
- Personal Action Under Section 343: Any member can file a direct lawsuit in their own name where directors exceed their statutory powers, breach member voting rights, or conduct an illegal transaction such as disposing of corporate undertakings without shareholder approval.
- Representative Action: A shareholder may sue on behalf of themselves and other affected minority members who share an identical commercial grievance against board conduct.
- Derivative Action Under Section 346: With leave of the Federal High Court, a member may initiate proceedings in the name and on behalf of the company to recover corporate property improperly diverted by directors to third parties or related entities.
Step-by-Step Procedure for Filing the Lawsuit
Litigating an unlawful disposal of undertaking involves distinct procedural stages before the Federal High Court:
- Selecting Originating Process: The suit is commenced either by Originating Summons where the dispute revolves around statutory interpretation of Section 342 and documentary evidence, or by Writ of Summons with Statement of Claim if there are contentious disputes regarding fraud, valuation, and asset ownership.
- Securing Urgent Ex Parte Injunctions: Concurrently with the substantive suit, counsel must file a Motion Ex Parte supported by an affidavit of urgency and an undertaking as to damages. This urgent motion seeks an interim order of injunction restraining the directors and prospective buyers from transferring, assigning, or alienating the company assets pending hearing of the motion on notice.
- Caveat and Notice to CAC: File a formal caveat or notification of pending litigation (lis pendens) with the Corporate Affairs Commission and the relevant State Land Registry to block any registration of deeds of assignment, mortgages, or changes in corporate ownership.
- Interlocutory Injunction Application: Argue the Motion on Notice for an interlocutory injunction to preserve the res (the disputed business undertaking) until final determination of the trial.
Reliefs and Remedies Available from the Court
The Federal High Court possesses extensive statutory powers under CAMA 2020 to restore the company financial equilibrium. Aggrieved shareholders should claim specific legal remedies:
- Declaration of Nullity: A formal judicial declaration that the board decision and subsequent contracts disposing of the undertaking violate Section 342(2) and are null, void, and of no legal effect.
- Order of Rescission: A judicial decree setting aside any deed of assignment, bill of sale, or transfer contract executed with the purchaser.
- Order for Restitution of Property: An order commanding the third-party purchaser to surrender possession and control of the undertaking back to the company.
- Account of Profits and Surcharge: An order compelling defaulting directors to account for all proceeds, secret commissions, or profits received and surcharging them personally for any losses sustained by the company.
The Position of Third-Party Purchasers
Third-party buyers often argue that they are bona fide purchasers for value without notice, attempting to shield themselves behind the indoor management rule. However, under Section 342, the disposal of a substantial corporate undertaking is a statutory matter of public law. Purchasers are expected to exercise due diligence by demanding a certified copy of the general meeting resolution filed at the CAC. If the buyer purchased corporate assets without confirming shareholder approval, Nigerian courts will not treat them as innocent purchasers, and the transaction will be set aside.