Filing a lawsuit to challenge an unlawful enforcement of a share pledge under CAMA 2020 requires a clear understanding of the statutory limits on a pledgee’s enforcement powers, the correct procedure for initiating court proceedings in Nigeria, and the interim reliefs that are available to stop enforcement in its tracks before shares are permanently transferred away. Speed is essential because once pledged shares are transferred to a third-party buyer for value, recovery of the shares themselves becomes substantially more difficult.
A share pledge under CAMA 2020 is a security arrangement by which a shareholder (the pledgor) deposits shares in a company as collateral for a debt or obligation owed to a lender or creditor (the pledgee). Upon a default event, the pledgee acquires a contractual right to enforce the pledge, typically by selling or transferring the pledged shares to recover the outstanding debt. However, that enforcement right is not absolute. It is subject to specific statutory and contractual conditions that, if not strictly observed, render the enforcement unlawful and give the pledgor full grounds for court challenge.
Grounds for Challenging Enforcement as Unlawful
The following are the principal grounds on which an enforcement of a share pledge may be challenged as unlawful under Nigerian law:
- No valid default has occurred: The pledgee purports to enforce without a genuine qualifying default, or the alleged default is disputed as failing to satisfy the precise contractual definition of a default event
- Enforcement procedure was not followed: The pledgee failed to issue the required demand notice, did not observe the contractual cure period granted to the pledgor, or transferred the shares without obtaining any court order where the pledge agreement required one
- Shares were sold at undervalue: The pledgee disposed of the pledged shares at a price grossly below prevailing market value without taking reasonable steps to achieve the best available price, causing unconscionable financial loss to the pledgor
- The pledge agreement is itself invalid: The pledge was not properly constituted, for example because the required board resolutions were absent, the share certificate was never properly deposited, or the pledge was not registered as a charge with CAC where registration was required under CAMA 2020
- Economic duress or unconscionable bargain: The pledgor executed the pledge agreement under economic duress or the enforcement is being weaponised to expropriate the pledgor’s shareholding rather than to legitimately recover a genuine debt
Immediate Pre-Litigation Steps
Before filing any court process, the pledgor must take the following urgent steps to protect their position and preserve the share register status quo:
- Write a formal legal letter to the pledgee immediately upon receiving any enforcement notice, specifically disputing the claimed default and invoking any contractual cure period that remains available
- Notify the company secretary of the company whose shares are pledged in writing, directing the company not to register any transfer of the pledged shares in its register of members pending resolution of the dispute
- Instruct a qualified solicitor to review the pledge agreement, default notice, and all relevant correspondence and identify the specific legal grounds on which enforcement can be resisted
- Obtain an independent share valuation from a registered valuator to establish the market value of the pledged shares as at the date of the purported enforcement, for use in quantifying damages if the shares are ultimately not recoverable
Applying for an Interlocutory Injunction
The most critical immediate step in challenging an unlawful share pledge enforcement in Nigeria is obtaining an interlocutory injunction from the Federal High Court to restrain the pledgee from completing, registering, or acting on any purported transfer or sale of the pledged shares, pending the determination of the substantive claim. Once pledged shares are transferred to an innocent third-party purchaser for value without notice of the dispute, the pledgor’s prospect of physically recovering those shares is dramatically reduced and the remedy may be limited to damages only.
To obtain an interlocutory injunction, the applicant (pledgor) must satisfy the court on three points derived from the principles in American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd as applied by Nigerian courts:
- That there is a serious question to be tried, meaning the challenge to the enforcement raises arguable and non-frivolous points of law or disputed facts that merit trial
- That the balance of convenience favours granting the injunction, meaning the prejudice to the pledgor if the injunction is refused outweighs the inconvenience to the pledgee if it is granted and the pledgee is temporarily prevented from completing the enforcement
- That damages would not be an adequate remedy for the pledgor if the injunction is refused and the pledgor later succeeds at trial, particularly where the pledged shares carry irreplaceable control rights, special voting powers, or strategic value that cannot be straightforwardly compensated by an award of money
The injunction application should be made on notice to the pledgee and heard on urgency. In cases where the enforcement is imminent and giving notice to the pledgee would defeat the purpose of the application, an ex parte temporary restraining order may be sought from the court and is typically effective for between seven and fourteen days until a full inter partes hearing can be convened.
Filing the Main Court Action
The substantive action challenging the unlawful enforcement must be filed in the Federal High Court, which has exclusive jurisdiction over matters arising under CAMA 2020 including disputes about share ownership, share transfers, company register entries, and enforcement of security interests over company shares. The action may be commenced by originating summons supported by a verifying affidavit where the relevant facts are largely undisputed and the dispute turns principally on legal interpretation of the pledge agreement or the applicable statutory provisions. Where material facts are substantially in dispute and oral evidence will be needed, the action should be commenced by writ of summons and statement of claim instead.
The reliefs to be claimed in the substantive action should include:
- A declaration that the enforcement of the share pledge was unlawful, invalid, and of no legal effect
- An order setting aside any purported transfer of the pledged shares and cancelling any resulting share certificate or registration in the company’s share register
- An order directing the company to restore the pledgor’s name in the register of members as the rightful holder of the pledged shares
- General and special damages for all financial loss suffered as a direct result of the unlawful enforcement
- An account of all dividends received, distributions made, and voting rights exercised in respect of the pledged shares during the period of unlawful dispossession
- Costs of the proceedings assessed on an indemnity basis given the nature of the wrongdoing
SEC and NGX Dimensions for Listed Companies
Where the pledged shares are in a company listed on the Nigerian Exchange Group (NGX), the unlawful enforcement may additionally engage the regulatory jurisdiction of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the NGX itself. The pledgor should consider filing a simultaneous complaint with the Investments and Securities Tribunal (IST) established under the Investments and Securities Act 2025, which has jurisdiction over securities-related disputes including unlawful share transfers in listed companies. The IST can grant injunctive relief and award compensation independently of the Federal High Court action, providing an additional and potentially faster avenue for relief where listed shares are at risk.