Challenging an unlawful forfeiture of shares under CAMA 2020 requires filing an originating process before the Federal High Court, seeking declaratory orders that the purported forfeiture is null and void, an order of rectification of the company register of members, and an injunction restraining the company from re-allotting or selling the shares. The action is grounded in strict non-compliance with the company Articles of Association and statutory procedural safeguards governing calls on shares under Sections 165 to 170 of CAMA 2020.
The Nature and Doctrine of Share Forfeiture
Forfeiture of shares is an extraordinary, confiscatory legal remedy that deprives a shareholder of their proprietary equity rights in an incorporated company. Because forfeiture results in total expropriation of property, Nigerian courts apply the strict common law principle of strictissimi juris. Under this doctrine, any irregularity in the procedure, however slight or technical, renders the entire forfeiture null, void, and of no legal effect.
A company possesses no inherent statutory right to forfeit shares. The power must be explicitly granted in the company Articles of Association. Furthermore, shares can only be forfeited for non-payment of calls made on unpaid share capital. A board of directors cannot legally forfeit shares to enforce ordinary commercial debts, contractual disputes, or disciplinary claims against a shareholder.
Mandatory Statutory Steps for a Lawful Forfeiture
To withstand judicial scrutiny, a company must execute four mandatory procedural steps with absolute accuracy:
- Valid Call by a Properly Constituted Board: The call must be authorized by a resolution passed at a board meeting possessing a legitimate statutory quorum. The directors must make the call strictly in accordance with limits set in the Articles regarding timing and amounts.
- Service of Formal Call Notice: The company must serve a written notice on the member under Section 244 of CAMA 2020, specifying the exact amount due, the bank or office where payment must be remitted, and a payment deadline not less than fourteen days from the date of service.
- Notice of Intention to Forfeit: If the call remains unpaid after the deadline, the directors must issue a second statutory notice. This warning notice must specify a further payment date (at least fourteen days later) and explicitly state that non-payment on or before that date will render the shares liable to forfeiture.
- Board Resolution of Forfeiture: Only after the second deadline has expired without payment can the board convene and pass a formal resolution declaring the designated shares forfeited.
Common Legal Grounds for Challenging Forfeiture
A shareholder seeking to overturn a share forfeiture can rely on several established legal grounds:
- Defective Notice: Failure to provide the full fourteen days notice, omitting mandatory payment details, or serving notice at the wrong address invalidates the process completely.
- Invalid Board Composition: If the board of directors was inquorate, if interested directors voted without declaring conflicts of interest under Section 306, or if directors were invalidly appointed, the resulting forfeiture resolution is void.
- Oppressive and Unfairly Prejudicial Conduct: Under Section 353 of CAMA 2020, if majority directors make selective or discriminatory calls designed to squeeze out minority shareholders while granting extensions to themselves, the court will set aside the forfeiture.
- Unauthorized Subject Matter: Attempting to forfeit fully paid shares or shares pledged as security outside statutory call provisions is illegal.
Litigation Procedure at the Federal High Court
Under Section 251(1)(e) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended), the Federal High Court exercises exclusive original jurisdiction over disputes concerning the operation, regulation, and management of companies incorporated under CAMA.
The aggrieved shareholder initiates the lawsuit by filing an Originating Summons (where the matter turns primarily on interpreting CAMA and the Articles without major disputes of fact) or a Writ of Summons accompanied by a Statement of Claim (where bad faith, fraudulent collusion, or contested payments are at issue). The plaintiff must claim specific reliefs:
- A declaration that the call on shares and the notice of intention to forfeit were defective, unlawful, null, and void.
- A declaration that the board resolution purporting to forfeit the plaintiff shares is illegal and of no legal effect.
- An order of perpetual injunction restraining the company, its directors, and agents from selling, transferring, cancelling, or re-allotting the forfeited shares.
- An order under Section 115 of CAMA 2020 directing the company to rectify its Register of Members by restoring the plaintiff name as the lawful holder of the shares.
- An order compelling the company to account for and pay all dividends and corporate distributions withheld during the period of purported forfeiture.
Urgent Interim Injunctions and CAC Notification
Time is critical in forfeiture litigation because the company may promptly sell the shares to a bona fide third-party purchaser, complicating restitution. Simultaneously with the originating process, the plaintiff counsel should file a Motion on Notice for an Interlocutory Injunction supported by an Affidavit of Urgency to preserve the res.
Additionally, counsel should issue a formal notice of lis pendens to the Corporate Affairs Commission. This administrative notification places a formal caveat on the company file at CAC, alerting the Commission not to accept or register any return of allotments or status updates reflecting the altered shareholding until the Federal High Court delivers judgment.