Challenging an unlawful forfeiture of shares under CAMA 2020 requires instituting an action before the Federal High Court seeking declaratory orders that the forfeiture is null and void, an injunction restraining the company from re-allotting the shares, and an order directing the rectification of the register of members. Under Nigerian company law, forfeiture is regarded as a drastic expropriatory measure, meaning courts require companies to follow strict statutory and procedural rules before any forfeiture can stand.
The Legal Doctrine of Strict Compliance (Strictissimi Juris)
Nigerian courts consistently hold that the power of forfeiture is strictissimi juris. A company attempting to forfeit unpaid or partly paid shares must adhere strictly to every procedural requirement contained in the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 and the company’s Articles of Association.
Any irregularity, whether a defect in the formal demand notice, incorrect interest calculation, improper board meeting notice, or lack of a valid quorum, invalidates the entire forfeiture exercise. Equity leans against forfeiture, and the burden of proving absolute regularity rests squarely upon the company and its board of directors.
Actionable Grounds for Invalidating a Share Forfeiture
An aggrieved shareholder can successfully challenge a purported forfeiture on several robust legal grounds:
- Defective Statutory Notice of Call: The company must issue a formal call notice giving the shareholder a statutory notice period of at least fourteen days to make payment. The notice must specify the exact amount due, the bank account details, and explicitly warn that failure to pay will result in forfeiture. Omitting any of these details renders the notice fundamentally defective.
- Improperly Constituted Board: The resolution making the call or authorizing the forfeiture must be passed at a duly convened meeting of directors. If disqualified directors voted, or if the board lacked a quorum, the resulting resolution is ultra vires and legally void.
- Collateral and Malicious Purpose: Directors owe a fiduciary duty under Section 305 of CAMA 2020 to exercise powers in good faith for the benefit of the company as a whole. Using forfeiture as an oppressive weapon to silence a minority shareholder, dilute opposition, or hijack company control constitutes an abuse of fiduciary power.
- Tender of Payment Before Actual Forfeiture: If the shareholder tendered the unpaid call amount along with accrued interest prior to the board’s formal forfeiture resolution, any subsequent forfeiture resolution is invalid.
Step-by-Step Procedure for Filing the Lawsuit
Pursuant to Section 251(1)(e) of the 1999 Constitution of Nigeria (as amended), the Federal High Court exercises exclusive original jurisdiction over disputes arising from the operation and management of companies registered under CAMA. The litigation procedure entails the following steps:
- Selecting the Originating Process: If the dispute turns primarily on documentary interpretation and statutory non-compliance, file an Originating Summons supported by an affidavit and written address. Where there are contested allegations of fraud or director bad faith, commence the action via a Writ of Summons accompanied by a Statement of Claim.
- Urgent Motion for Interlocutory Injunction: Concurrently file a Motion on Notice for an Interlocutory Injunction to restrain the directors from selling, re-issuing, transferring, or cancelling the disputed shares until the final determination of the substantive suit.
- Joining Necessary Parties: Name the company as the primary defendant, the individual directors who authorized the unlawful act as co-defendants, and where appropriate, join the Corporate Affairs Commission as a nominal party to ensure enforceability of registry orders.
- Lodging a Lis Pendens Caveat with CAC: Serve a certified copy of the filed court papers and notice of pending litigation upon the CAC to halt any unilateral corporate updates altering the company’s official shareholding status report.
Substantive Reliefs to Claim in the Court Process
The plaintiff’s statement of claim or originating summons must seek comprehensive legal and equitable remedies:
- Declaratory Relief: A declaration that the purported call and subsequent forfeiture of the plaintiff’s shares violate CAMA 2020 and the articles of association, and are therefore ultra vires, null, and void.
- Statutory Rectification: An order pursuant to Section 115 of CAMA 2020 commanding the company to rectify its register of members by restoring the plaintiff’s name and full equity holdings.
- Perpetual Injunction: An order perpetually restraining the company and directors from interfering with the plaintiff’s membership rights, voting privileges, and entitlement to accrued dividends.
- Damages: An award of substantial general damages for unlawful exclusion and economic loss suffered during the period of purported disenfranchisement.
Protecting Minority Shareholder Rights
Where the illegal forfeiture forms part of a wider pattern of unfair prejudice or oppressive conduct, the affected shareholder can also incorporate an application for relief under Sections 353 and 354 of CAMA 2020. This allows the court wide remedial powers, including regulating the future conduct of the company affairs or directing the controlling majority to purchase the minority’s shares at a court-determined fair valuation.