To challenge an unlawful merger or scheme of arrangement under CAMA 2020, an aggrieved shareholder or creditor must file an originating summons or a notice of objection before the Federal High Court, invoking its exclusive jurisdiction under Section 251 of the 1999 Constitution and Sections 711 to 715 of CAMA 2020. Depending on whether the objection targets anti-competitive market concentration or internal corporate oppression, the challenge can also be initiated before the Competition and Consumer Protection Tribunal (CCPT) against clearance granted by the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC).
Mergers, corporate reorganizations, and schemes of arrangement alter shareholder equity rights, creditor security priority, and market competition. When corporate boards orchestrate transactions tainted by procedural non-compliance, fraudulent undervaluation, or oppression of minority interests, Nigerian law provides clear judicial mechanisms to halt or invalidate the restructuring.
Primary Legal Grounds for Challenging a Merger or Scheme
Litigants challenging a scheme of arrangement or corporate amalgamation must anchor their lawsuit upon concrete statutory violations:
- Procedural Non-Compliance and Notice Defects: Under Section 715 of CAMA 2020, every affected shareholder and creditor is entitled to statutory 21-day notice of the court-ordered meeting, accompanied by an explanatory statement disclosing the full financial impact of the scheme and any director conflicts of interest. Omitting material disclosures or failing to serve notices in the prescribed manner renders subsequent resolutions voidable.
- Oppressive or Unfairly Prejudicial Conduct: Under Section 353 and Section 354 of CAMA 2020, minority shareholders can challenge schemes designed to squeeze them out at coercive or artificially depressed share exchange ratios. Nigerian courts reject restructuring plans where majority shareholders use corporate machinery to enrich themselves at the expense of dissenters.
- Violation of Competition and Antitrust Laws: Under the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act 2018 (FCCPA), mergers that result in a substantial lessening of competition or create abusive market dominance are unlawful. A competitor or consumer association can challenge an unnotified or unlawfully approved transaction.
- Fraud, Collusion, or Concealment: If the scheme document misrepresents company asset values, conceals contingent liabilities, or relies on fraudulent financial statements, the court will refuse sanction or overturn an order obtained through deception.
Step-by-Step Judicial Process at the Federal High Court
The Federal High Court holds exclusive jurisdiction over corporate restructuring under CAMA. Aggrieved parties should pursue the following procedural course:
- Lodge Formal Objections at the Sanction Hearing: When the merging entities file their joint petition under Section 711 or 715 praying the court to sanction the approved scheme, the challenger must file a Notice of Intention to Oppose supported by an affidavit detailing the illegality, financial prejudice, or procedural flaws.
- File an Independent Action Under Section 353: If the petition has not yet been filed, dissenting shareholders holding at least ten percent of the issued shares or qualifying as oppressed members can institute an originating summons seeking interlocutory injunctions to restrain the holding of the court-ordered meeting.
- Serve Necessary Parties and Regulators: The lawsuit must join the merging companies, the board of directors, and relevant statutory regulators, specifically the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC), the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and the FCCPC.
- Seek Restraining Orders Against CAC Registration: Under Section 715(4) of CAMA 2020, a scheme order takes effect only when a certified true copy is delivered to the CAC for registration. The claimant must urgently apply for an interim or interlocutory injunction restraining the CAC from accepting or registering any court sanction order pending trial.
Available Judicial Remedies and Court Powers
Upon hearing the dispute, the Federal High Court exercises extensive statutory powers under Section 355 and Section 715 of CAMA 2020:
- Refusal of Sanction: The court possesses absolute discretion to refuse to sanction a scheme if it determines that the arrangement is not fair and reasonable to all classes of shareholders.
- Court-Ordered Share Buyout (Appraisal Rights): The judge can direct the acquiring entity or controlling shareholders to purchase the dissenting members shares at a fair market value assessed by an independent court-appointed valuation expert.
- Setting Aside a Sanction Order: Where a sanction was secured through fraud, perjury, or material concealment, the court possesses inherent jurisdiction to set aside its own enrolled order ab initio.
- Award of Restitutionary Damages: Directing the restoration of corporate assets transferred unlawfully under the voided arrangement.
Challenging Regulatory Approvals at the Competition Tribunal
Where an objection rests primarily on antitrust and market distortion grounds, the claimant can file an appeal before the Competition and Consumer Protection Tribunal (CCPT) against an FCCPC merger clearance. The CCPT can suspend the merger approval, order divestitures, or impose administrative penalties under Section 96 of the FCCPA.
By enforcing these statutory procedures before the Federal High Court and appellate tribunals, investors and creditors protect their proprietary rights against unlawful corporate schemes.