To challenge an unlawful refusal by company directors to convene an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, aggrieved shareholders holding at least one-tenth of the voting capital can convene the meeting themselves under Section 239, or file an originating summons at the Federal High Court pursuant to Section 240 seeking a judicial order compelling the meeting. The Federal High Court exercises exclusive jurisdiction over internal corporate disputes under Section 251(1)(e) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999.
Statutory Right of Shareholders to Requisition an EGM
Under Section 239(1) of CAMA 2020, directors of a company have a mandatory statutory duty to convene an extraordinary general meeting whenever members holding at least one-tenth of the paid-up capital of the company carrying voting rights deposit a formal requisition at the registered office. For companies without share capital, the threshold is one-tenth of the total voting rights of all members.
The requisition must state the specific objects of the meeting, such as the removal of errant directors, forensic examination of accounts, or restructuring of share capital. Once deposited, the directors must proceed to convene the meeting within twenty-one days from the date of deposit.
Self-Help Remedy Under Section 239(4)
Before initiating litigation, CAMA 2020 equips requisitioning members with an immediate self-help mechanism. If the board of directors fails to convene the meeting within twenty-one days, the requisitionists, or any of them representing more than one-half of the total voting rights of all of them, may convene the meeting themselves.
Key statutory features of self-convened meetings include:
- Three-Month Window: The self-convened EGM must be held within three months from the initial date the requisition was deposited at the registered office.
- Identical Meeting Procedure: The meeting must be convened in the same manner, as nearly as possible, as that in which meetings are convened by the board of directors, including issuing standard twenty-one-day notices.
- Reimbursement of Expenses: All reasonable expenses incurred by the requisitioning shareholders by reason of the directors failure to convene the meeting must be reimbursed by the company. CAMA 2020 empowers the company to deduct these refunded sums from the salaries, sitting fees, or other remuneration of the defaulting directors.
Filing an Originating Summons Under Section 240
Where directors actively frustrate the self-help mechanism by locking company premises, intimidating shareholders, or threatening violence, the requisitioning members must approach the Federal High Court under Section 240. This section authorizes the court to order a meeting to be called, held, and conducted in any manner the court considers appropriate.
Litigation counsel must assemble and file the following originating court processes:
- Originating Summons: Formulating legal questions for judicial determination regarding the statutory interpretation of Sections 239 and 240 of CAMA 2020, supported by specific declarative and injunctive reliefs.
- Affidavit in Support: Deposition detailing the applicant shareholding, the deposit of the requisition notice, proof of dispatch via courier or personal service at the registered office, the expiration of twenty-one days without board action, and the bad faith of the directors.
- Statutory Exhibits: Attaching certified true copies of the CAC status report proving shareholding, the formal requisition letter, courier dispatch slips, and relevant clauses of the company articles of association.
- Written Address: Legal submissions demonstrating that convening the meeting has become impracticable without judicial intervention, citing binding appellate authorities on shareholder democracy.
Reliefs and Protective Court Orders
In addition to seeking an order commanding the holding of the EGM, plaintiffs typically request protective orders to preserve the subject matter of the dispute:
- Appointment of Independent Meeting Chairman: An order designating an independent senior legal practitioner, an accredited insolvency practitioner, or a representative from the Corporate Affairs Commission to chair the judicially mandated EGM.
- Quorum Modification: Under Section 240(2), the court can direct that one member present in person or by proxy shall be deemed to constitute a valid quorum, neutralizing director boycott tactics.
- Interlocutory Injunctions: Restraining the defendant directors from dissipating corporate assets, allotting unissued shares, altering board composition, or borrowing funds pending the holding of the court-ordered meeting.
Filing Court Orders with the Corporate Affairs Commission
Upon obtaining the enrolled order of the Federal High Court, the plaintiffs must serve the order on the company directors, the company secretary, and the Corporate Affairs Commission. The CAC records the court order against the corporate profile and sends official observers to monitor deliberations at the judicially mandated EGM, ensuring that all approved resolutions are accepted for formal CAC registration.