To challenge the unlawful removal of a Managing Director under CAMA 2020, the aggrieved executive must file an action before the Federal High Court by way of Originating Summons or Writ of Summons, seeking declaratory orders that the removal violated statutory due process, an injunction restraining the company from altering CAC records, and compensatory damages for breach of contract. Under Sections 288 and 302 of CAMA 2020, a Managing Director possesses a dual legal status as both a statutory director and an executive employee, each governed by distinct legal rules.
Understanding the Dual Status of a Managing Director
A Managing Director is first a director elected by the members or appointed by the board, and second, an executive employee engaged under a contract of service. Nigerian company jurisprudence distinguishes between removal from the office of director under company law and termination of the contract of employment under labor law.
While the board of directors can withdraw executive managerial responsibilities under the articles of association, the company cannot strip a Managing Director of ordinary directorship without strictly adhering to the statutory removal machinery provided in Section 288 of CAMA 2020.
Mandatory Statutory Removal Procedure Under Section 288
Section 288 sets out the non-negotiable procedure for removing any director before the expiration of their term of office. Any removal that departs from these steps is void:
- Special Notice Requirement: The company must receive a special notice of twenty-eight days of the proposed resolution to remove the director before the general meeting at which the vote will occur.
- Service of Notice on Director: The company secretary must immediately dispatch a copy of the notice to the Managing Director.
- Right of Written Representation: The Managing Director is entitled to make written representations of reasonable length and request that the company circulate these representations to all members entitled to attend the meeting.
- Right to be Heard: The Managing Director has an unfettered statutory right to attend the general meeting and speak in defense of their stewardship before any vote is taken.
- Resolution of the General Meeting: A director can only be removed by an ordinary resolution passed at a general meeting of members. The board of directors has no statutory power to remove a co-director from the board by board resolution alone.
Grounds for Filing the Lawsuit
An unlawful removal lawsuit succeeds when the plaintiff proves specific legal defects in the company actions:
- Breach of Section 288 Procedures: Failure to give special notice, withholding the notice from the director, or denying the executive the platform to circulate written representations or speak at the general meeting.
- Violation of Section 36 Fair Hearing: Depriving the Managing Director of procedural fair hearing guaranteed by Section 36 of the 1999 Constitution when allegations of fraud or gross misconduct are raised.
- Board Usurpation of Powers: Attempting to terminate board membership via a board room circular resolution without member ratification at a general meeting.
- Breach of Executive Service Agreement: Unilateral termination without the required contractual notice period or payment of contractual severance compensation.
Jurisdiction and Judicial Forum
Under Section 251(1)(e) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999, the Federal High Court exercises exclusive jurisdiction over disputes concerning the operation, management, and regulation of companies registered under CAMA. If the claim focuses on wrongful removal from directorship, invalidation of board meetings, and rectification of CAC registers, the suit must be instituted at the Federal High Court.
Conversely, if the primary relief sought is wrongful dismissal damages under an employment contract, the National Industrial Court of Nigeria (NICN) possesses exclusive jurisdiction under Section 254C. In corporate practice, counsel files the challenge to directorship status and corporate resolutions at the Federal High Court, while invoking Section 288(6) to preserve contractual compensation claims.
Litigation Process and Reliefs Sought
Counsel initiates the action with an Originating Summons or Writ supported by an affidavit, board resolutions, company articles, employment contracts, and CAC status extracts. The reliefs claimed include:
- A declaration that the resolution removing the Managing Director is null, void, and of no legal effect.
- An order of perpetual injunction restraining the company from submitting CAC Form 7 or removing the director name from the CAC portal.
- An order restraining the remaining directors from preventing the Managing Director from attending board meetings and exercising executive functions.
- Substantial damages for breach of executive contract, loss of office, and defamation under Section 288(6) of CAMA 2020.