To challenge an unlawful variation of class rights under Section 167 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 (CAMA 2020), shareholders holding not less than fifteen percent of the issued shares of the affected class who did not consent to or vote in favour of the variation resolution must file an originating summons at the Federal High Court within twenty-one days after the date on which the consent was given or the resolution was passed. This statutory twenty-one-day deadline is strictly jurisdictional and cannot be extended by judicial discretion, and the court will cancel the variation if satisfied that the corporate alteration unfairly prejudices the shareholders of the affected class.
Statutory Concept of Class Rights and Variation Under CAMA 2020
Under Section 165 of CAMA 2020, shares in a company may be divided into different classes, each bearing distinct rights regarding dividend participation, voting power, capital return upon winding up, or redemption features.
Section 166 governs how such rights may be varied. Where the articles of association prescribe a specific procedure for varying class rights, that procedure must be followed strictly. In the absence of specific provisions in the articles, class rights can only be varied with the written consent of the holders of three-quarters of the issued shares of that class or by a special resolution passed at a separate general meeting of the holders of the issued shares of that class.
A variation occurs not only when rights are directly revoked, but also when the commercial value or substantive power of a class is altered, such as issuing a new super-voting tier or subordinating preference dividend entitlements.
Strict Jurisdictional Thresholds and Standing Requirements
Litigants seeking to challenge an alleged variation must satisfy rigid preliminary criteria established under Section 167(1) of CAMA 2020 before the Federal High Court can assume jurisdiction.
First, the applicants must collectively hold not less than fifteen percent of the issued shares of the specific class whose rights are being varied. Holding fifteen percent of the total equity of the company is insufficient if the applicants do not hold fifteen percent of the affected class itself.
Second, none of the applicants must have consented to or voted in support of the resolution approving the variation. Casting an affirmative vote or signing a written waiver permanently estops the shareholder from seeking relief under this section.
Third, the application must be initiated within twenty-one days from the date the resolution was passed or consent given. Nigerian appellate courts have affirmed that statutory time bars of this nature operate as an absolute limitation, extinguishing the right of action upon expiry.
Step-by-Step Procedure for Filing the Legal Challenge
- Audit Shareholder Register and Class Holdings: Immediately verify the share register to confirm that the dissenting coalition controls at least fifteen percent of the affected share class and that all members formally dissented or abstained.
- Formulate Originating Summons: Draft the originating summons pursuant to the Federal High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules and Section 167 of CAMA 2020, articulating questions for determination regarding whether the variation resolution is procedurally flawed or unfairly prejudicial.
- Draft Comprehensive Affidavit in Support: Compile an extensive affidavit setting out the historical rights attached to the class shares, the financial dilution or loss of control caused by the variation, and the minutes of the class meeting showing the dissent.
- File Action and Serve Processes on Company: File the suit at the Federal High Court registry within the twenty-one-day limitation window and effect prompt personal service on the company at its registered office address.
- Motion for Interlocutory Injunction: Concurrently file a motion on notice restraining the company and the board of directors from implementing the variation, issuing new shares, or notifying the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) pending determination of the substantive suit.
- Hearing and Judicial Determination: Present legal arguments showing unfair prejudice under Section 167(3); if the court finds in favour of the applicants, it makes an order cancelling the variation.
- Mandatory Lodgment of Court Order with CAC: Serve the certified true copy of the court order on the company, triggering its statutory duty to deliver the order to the CAC within fifteen days.
Key Evidentiary Exhibits Required for the Originating Process
- Certified True Copy of the Memorandum and Articles of Association: Demonstrates the foundational rights, voting privileges, and variation mechanisms originally attached to the class shares.
- Share Certificates and Central Securities Clearing System (CSCS) Statements: Concrete documentary proof establishing that the applicants hold at least fifteen percent of the specific share class.
- Minutes of the General or Class Meeting: Verifies that the applicants voted against the resolution or formally recorded their dissent in writing.
- Corporate Valuation and Forensic Financial Report: Expert financial analysis demonstrating how the variation imposes disproportionate economic harm or voting dilution on the class members.
- Notice of Meeting and Explanatory Circulars: Highlights any material non-disclosures or misleading representations made by the board prior to the vote.
Statutory Notification of CAC and Default Sanctions
The resolution of a class rights dispute carries mandatory statutory reporting duties backed by personal criminal liability for corporate officers.
Under Section 167(4) of CAMA 2020, the company must deliver a certified true copy of the court order to the CAC within fifteen days after the order is made. This ensures that the public registry accurately reflects whether the variation has been confirmed or cancelled. If a company defaults in delivering the copy of the order to the CAC, the company and every officer in default commit an offence and are liable to a statutory penalty for every day the default continues.