Filing a lawsuit to challenge an unlawful variation of a debenture stock trust deed under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020 requires careful attention to standing, jurisdiction, the grounds available, and the specific provisions of the trust deed itself. The Federal High Court is the court with jurisdiction over company matters under Section 251 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999, and it is in that court that such a challenge must be commenced.
A debenture stock trust deed is a formal document under which a company creates a class of debenture stock, appoints a trustee to hold security on behalf of the debenture stockholders, and sets out the rights and obligations of all parties. The trust deed governs the terms under which the company may borrow, the security provided, the interest rate, the redemption terms, and the rights of the trustee and the debenture stockholders. Any variation to these terms that is not carried out in accordance with the deed and the requirements of CAMA 2020 is potentially unlawful and open to challenge.
The relevant provisions of CAMA 2020 governing debentures and debenture trust deeds are found in Part F, Sections 193 to 220 of the Act. Section 207 of CAMA 2020 makes specific provision for the rights of debenture holders, and Section 208 addresses the powers of the court in relation to debentures. These provisions, read together with the general law of trusts and contract law applicable in Nigeria, form the legal basis for a challenge to an unlawful variation.
Common grounds on which a variation of a debenture stock trust deed may be challenged include the following:
- The variation was made without the consent of the requisite majority of debenture stockholders as required by the deed or by CAMA 2020
- The variation was made in a manner that discriminates unfairly between different classes of debenture stockholders
- The trustee consented to a variation that was outside the scope of the powers granted to the trustee under the deed
- The variation purports to reduce or extinguish the security held by the trustee for the benefit of debenture stockholders without proper authority
- The company directors approved the variation without proper board authority or in breach of their fiduciary duties under CAMA 2020
- The variation was procured by fraud or misrepresentation made to the trustee or to the debenture stockholders
The steps for filing a lawsuit to challenge the unlawful variation are as follows:
- Establish Standing: Not everyone can bring this action. The persons with standing to challenge an unlawful variation of a debenture stock trust deed include individual debenture stockholders, the trustee of the deed acting on behalf of all stockholders, or a group of debenture stockholders holding a sufficient percentage of the outstanding debenture stock as specified in the deed. If you are an individual debenture stockholder, you must first review the deed to understand whether you must proceed through the trustee or whether the deed permits direct action by individual stockholders.
- Review the Trust Deed: Before commencing any litigation, a careful reading of the trust deed is essential. The deed will set out the variation procedure, the majority required for a valid variation (often three-quarters in value of the outstanding debenture stock), any consent requirements for the trustee, and any dispute resolution mechanism including arbitration clauses. If the deed contains an arbitration clause, the dispute may need to go to arbitration rather than court in the first instance, subject to arguments about whether the particular challenge falls within the scope of the arbitration clause.
- Send a Pre-Action Notice: Nigerian courts generally expect parties to comply with pre-action notice requirements before filing certain types of claims. While the Companies Act does not always specify a mandatory pre-action notice for company law challenges, it is good practice to write formally to the company and the trustee identifying the unlawful variation complained of and demanding that it be reversed or that the parties engage in settlement discussions. This letter is also useful evidence of the claimant good faith if the matter proceeds to court.
- Prepare and File the Originating Process: The claim may be commenced by way of an Originating Summons (where the facts are largely undisputed and the issue is one of legal construction) or a Writ of Summons (where there are disputed facts that need to be resolved by evidence). In the Federal High Court, the claimant files the originating process along with a supporting affidavit, written address, and the exhibits including the trust deed and all documents evidencing the variation complained of. The appropriate filing fees are paid at the court registry.
- Serve the Defendants: The company and the trustee of the debenture stock trust deed must be served with the originating process in accordance with the Federal High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules. Service on the company is effected at its registered office address as shown in the CAC register. Service on a corporate trustee is similarly effected at the trustee registered address. The court will not proceed with the substantive hearing until proper service is confirmed.
- Apply for Interim Relief if Urgent: If the unlawful variation is causing immediate or ongoing harm to the debenture stockholders, the claimant should apply for an interlocutory injunction to restrain the company from taking any further steps to implement the variation pending the determination of the substantive action. The claimant must satisfy the court that there is a serious question to be tried, that damages would not be an adequate remedy, and that the balance of convenience favours the grant of the injunction.
- Proceed to Hearing: At the substantive hearing, the court will consider the terms of the trust deed, the requirements of CAMA 2020, any evidence of procedural irregularity in the variation, and the arguments of all parties before determining whether the variation was lawfully made. If the court finds the variation unlawful, it may order it to be set aside, order the company and trustee to restore the original deed terms, or award damages to affected stockholders.
Under Section 208 of CAMA 2020, where a debenture holder considers that the company has acted or is acting in a manner unfairly prejudicial to the interests of debenture holders, the court has power to make such order as it thinks fit to give relief in respect of the matters complained of. This provision gives the court broad remedial powers including the power to order the company to rectify the variation, to appoint a receiver, or to make any other order that is just in the circumstances.
From a CAC perspective, companies that issue debenture stock are required to file a copy of the trust deed with CAC under Section 222 of CAMA 2020 as part of the charge registration process. Any material variation to a registered debenture stock trust deed may also need to be notified to CAC depending on whether the variation affects the terms of the registered charge. Companies and trustees should take legal advice on whether a particular variation triggers a separate CAC filing obligation.
Debenture stockholders who believe a variation of the trust deed has been unlawfully imposed should act promptly. Delay in bringing a challenge can be used against the claimant on the basis of the equitable doctrine of laches, particularly where the claimant has continued to accept interest payments or other benefits under the varied deed without protest. Taking swift legal action, even if only to send a formal letter of objection initially, preserves the claimant position and signals to the company and trustee that the variation will not be acquiesced in without a legal challenge.



