Under Section 144 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, holders of not less than 15 percent of the issued shares of a class who did not consent to or vote in favor of a resolution altering their class rights can file an originating summons at the Federal High Court to challenge and cancel the unlawful variation. The lawsuit must be filed within 21 days from the date the resolution was passed or consent was given, naming the company as the primary defendant and establishing that the variation unfairly prejudices the financial, dividend, or redemption entitlements of the preference shareholders.
Statutory Grounds for Challenging Unlawful Class Variation
Class rights attached to redeemable preference shares (such as cumulative dividend rates, preferential return of capital upon winding up, redemption premiums, and fixed redemption dates) enjoy statutory protection under CAMA 2020. A company cannot dilute or extinguish these rights through general shareholder majorities without following mandatory class consent mechanisms.
- Absence of Class Meeting or Quorum: Under Section 143, altering class rights requires the sanction of a special resolution passed at a separate class meeting of preference shareholders. Any alteration attempted at a general meeting without a distinct class vote is void ab initio.
- Failure to Secure Three-Fourths Class Majority: Statutory variation requires approval by holders of at least three-fourths of the issued shares of that specific preference class. Passing resolutions with simple majorities violates statutory safeguards.
- Unfair Commercial Prejudice: Even where procedural votes were technically obtained, dissenting shareholders can petition the court if the variation transfers commercial value unfairly to ordinary equity holders, cancels accumulated dividend arrears, or postpones agreed redemption timelines without adequate consideration.
- Infringement of Articles of Association: If the company articles contain entrenchment clauses or specific variation restrictions, any management attempt to circumvent these contractual protections constitutes an actionable illegality.
Step-by-Step Procedure for Filing at the Federal High Court
Litigation challenging shareholder rights variations falls under the exclusive jurisdiction of the Federal High Court pursuant to Section 251(1)(e) of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria. Plaintiffs must move swiftly due to strict limitation periods.
- Mobilization of Eligible Shareholding Threshold: The applicant or group of applicants must verify that they hold not less than 15 percent of the issued shares of the affected preference class and that none of the joining applicants voted in favor of the resolution.
- Calculation of the Strict 21-Day Statutory Window: The lawsuit must be filed within exactly 21 days after the date on which the resolution was passed or consent was given. Nigerian courts treat this timeline as jurisdictional, meaning filing on day 22 will result in summary dismissal for lack of jurisdiction.
- Drafting the Originating Summons and Affidavit: Legal counsel prepares an originating summons supported by an affidavit in support, a statement of material facts, and exhibits including the company articles of association, original share subscription agreements, class meeting minutes, and the disputed variation resolution.
- Application for Interim Injunction: Plaintiffs should contemporaneously file an ex parte motion for interim injunction to restrain the company, directors, and the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) from registering, implementing, or acting upon the disputed variation pending determination of the substantive suit.
- Service of Originating Processes: The originating summons must be served at the registered corporate office of the company in accordance with the Federal High Court Civil Procedure Rules.
Judicial Remedies and Orders Under CAMA 2020
Upon hearing the application, the Federal High Court possesses wide statutory discretion under Section 144(3) of CAMA 2020. The court can grant several protective orders depending on the circumstances.
- Cancellation of Variation: If the court is satisfied that the variation would unfairly prejudice the shareholders represented by the applicant, it must make an order cancelling the variation resolution, restoring preference rights to their original legal status.
- Confirmation of Variation: If the applicant fails to establish unfair prejudice or jurisdictional compliance, the court will confirm the variation.
- Compulsory Buyout Order: Under minority protection powers in Section 353 and Section 354, the court may alternatively order the company or majority shareholders to purchase the petitioners preference shares at fair market value determined by an independent court-appointed financial valuer.
- Injunction Against CAC Registration: The court can issue a perpetual injunction prohibiting the CAC from accepting or indexing any altered return of allotments or amended articles reflecting the unlawful variation.
CAC Notification and Post-Judgment Compliance
Section 144(4) mandates that the company must deliver a certified true copy of any court order made on the application to the CAC within 15 days of the order being made. If the company fails to comply, the company and every officer in default commit an offence and are liable to daily default penalties prescribed by the Commission. Dissenting preference shareholders must independently forward certified court orders to the CAC to ensure corporate records remain accurate.