To challenge an unlawful variation of voting rights attached to preference shares under CAMA 2020, aggrieved preference shareholders holding not less than 15 percent of the issued shares of that class must file an originating summons or petition before the Federal High Court within 21 days after the variation resolution was passed. Under Section 167 of the Act, if this strict twenty-one-day limitation window expires, the right to judicial cancellation is extinguished, leaving affected investors unable to nullify the disputed alteration.
Preference shares typically carry preferential dividend rights and priority upon capital return during liquidation, but their voting rights are frequently restricted to specific statutory circumstances. However, where preference shares hold contractually entrenched voting privileges, common equity majorities frequently attempt to diminish, alter, or dilute those rights through general meeting resolutions without obtaining the separate statutory consent of the preference class.
Statutory Rules Governing Variation of Class Rights Under CAMA 2020
Section 166 and Section 167 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 provide stringent statutory safeguards for class rights. Where share capital is divided into different classes, the rights attached to any class cannot be altered, cancelled, or varied except in accordance with the provisions set out in the company articles of association.
In the absence of specific variation clauses within the articles, Section 166 mandates that class rights may only be varied if sanctioned by the consent in writing of the holders of at least three-quarters of the issued shares of that class, or through a special resolution passed at a separate general meeting of the holders of the issued preference shares.
Step-by-Step Procedure to Challenge Unlawful Variation in Court
- Verify Shareholding Qualification Threshold: Confirm that the applicants collectively hold not less than fifteen percent of the issued shares of the affected preference class. Furthermore, applicant shareholders must not have consented to or voted in favor of the variation resolution at the disputed meeting.
- Calculate Strict Twenty-One Day Filing Window: Compute twenty-one calendar days starting from the exact date the disputed variation resolution was approved. Nigerian courts strictly enforce this limitation period as an absolute statutory bar.
- Draft Originating Summons or Petition: Prepare an originating process at the Federal High Court pursuant to the Companies Proceedings Rules, seeking explicit declarations that the purported variation violates Section 166 and Section 167 of CAMA 2020.
- File Comprehensive Affidavit in Support: Accompany the originating process with a sworn affidavit outlining the history of the preference share issue, original voting covenants contained in the articles, minutes of the irregular meeting, and evidence of shareholder opposition.
- Attach Documentary Exhibits: Exhibit certified true copies of share certificates, the company Memorandum and Articles of Association (MEMART), the official notice convening the meeting, and the extract of the contentious resolution.
- Apply for Interlocutory Restraining Injunctions: File a motion on notice alongside an ex parte application seeking an order restraining the company, the board of directors, and the Corporate Affairs Commission from implementing, registering, or acting upon the variation resolution pending final judgment.
- Serve Formal Notice of Proceeding on CAC: Deliver a sealed copy of the filed court process to the Corporate Affairs Commission to put the regulatory registrar on notice and prevent the entry of modified class rights on the public register.
Grounds for Judicial Cancellation of Share Rights Variation
- Lack of Separate Class Meeting: Passing a blanket resolution at a combined general meeting of ordinary and preference shareholders without convening an independent meeting of the preference class renders the variation void ab initio.
- Failure to Secure Three-Quarters Majority: Failing to attain the mandatory seventy-five percent supermajority approval among the preference class members present and voting.
- Oppressive and Unfairly Prejudicial Conduct: Pleading unfair prejudice under Section 353 and Section 354 of CAMA 2020, demonstrating that the variation unfairly disadvantages preference holders to enrich ordinary shareholders.
- Breach of Express Constitutional Covenants: Violating explicit entrenched provisions in the company MEMART or underlying subscription agreements that protect voting thresholds.
Upon hearing the application, the Federal High Court possesses statutory authority under Section 167(4) to disallow and cancel the variation if it is satisfied that the alteration unfairly prejudices the shareholders of the class represented by the applicants.