To nullify an unauthorized transfer of company land in Nigeria, an aggrieved company or minority shareholder must file an action by Writ of Summons in the State High Court of the state where the land is situated, claiming declarations of invalidity, cancellation of registered deeds, and recovery of possession. Where rogue directors or unauthorized corporate officers execute fraudulent land conveyances without board approval or required shareholder sanctions under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, Nigerian courts will declare such alienations ultra vires, null, and void.
Real estate owned by an incorporated company forms part of its corporate assets and can only be alienated in strict compliance with the company Articles of Association, statutory board authorizations, and the Land Use Act 1978. Unauthorized land transfers often occur through forged board resolutions, fraudulent use of the company seal, or unauthorized signatures by single directors acting in breach of fiduciary duties.
Determining the Proper Court and Locus Standi
Establishing the correct judicial forum and legal capacity to sue is fundamental under Nigerian procedural law:
- State High Court Jurisdiction: Under Section 272 of the 1999 Constitution and Section 39 of the Land Use Act 1978, the State High Court where the landed property is physically located exercises exclusive subject-matter jurisdiction to adjudicate disputes regarding title to land, cancellation of deeds of assignment, and recovery of possession.
- The Company as Primary Claimant: Under the rule in Foss v Harbottle and Section 341 of CAMA 2020, the company itself is the proper plaintiff to sue for wrongs done to its property. A reconstituted board or liquidator can file the action directly in the corporate name of the company.
- Derivative Action by Minority Shareholders: If the controlling directors who executed the illegal conveyance refuse to sue themselves, minority shareholders must apply under Section 343 and Section 346 of CAMA 2020 for leave of court to commence a derivative action in the name and on behalf of the company to recover the land.
Pre-Litigation Investigations and Evidence Gathering
Before issuing court processes, litigation counsel must assemble an unassailable documentary audit to dismantle the fraudulent conveyance:
- Lands Registry Search: Conduct an official search at the State Lands Registry (such as the Lagos State Lands Bureau or Abuja Geographic Information Systems) to obtain certified true copies (CTCs) of the registered Deed of Assignment, Governor Consent file, and survey plans.
- Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) Search: Procure certified true copies of the company Memorandum and Articles of Association, current status report showing authentic directors, and recent annual returns to demonstrate that the individuals who signed the conveyance lacked corporate authorization.
- Minute Books and Board Resolutions: Review the official minute books of the company. Under Section 102 of CAMA 2020, executing a valid conveyance requires express board authorization. Proof that no valid board meeting was convened or that no resolution was passed establishes the ultra vires nature of the transfer.
- Forensic Handwriting Analysis: If director signatures or company seals were forged on the deed, engage an accredited police forensic document examiner to produce an official forensic handwriting analysis report.
Drafting the Originating Processes and Filing the Lawsuit
The claimant counsel commences the action by filing a Writ of Summons accompanied by a comprehensive Statement of Claim, Witness Statements on Oath, and frontloaded documentary exhibits. The lawsuit must name the rogue transferor, the third-party purchaser, the State Governor (or Attorney General), and the Registrar of Deeds as co-defendants.
Key reliefs to claim in the writ include: a declaration that the purported Deed of Assignment is ultra vires, null, void, and of no legal effect; an order setting aside the Governor Consent obtained on fraudulent representations under Section 26 of the Land Use Act; an order directing the Registrar of Titles to cancel the deed in the Lands Registry records; and an order of perpetual injunction restraining the defendants from entering or continuing trespass on the land.
Securing the Land with Urgent Interim Measures
To prevent the rogue buyer from quickly erecting structures or reselling the property to innocent third parties while litigation is pending, the claimant must file two urgent applications:
- Motion for Interlocutory Injunction: File a motion on notice accompanied by an affidavit of urgency and an undertaking as to damages, praying the court for an interlocutory injunction restraining the defendants from alienating, clearing, or developing the land pending the final judgment of the substantive suit.
- Registration of Lis Pendens and Caveat: Register a formal notice of pending litigation (Lis Pendens) and lodge a caveat at the State Lands Registry. This puts the entire world on constructive notice that the property is subject to active litigation, defeating any future claim by third-party buyers claiming to be bona fide purchasers for value without notice.
Statutory Protections Under Section 342 of CAMA 2020
Under Section 342 of CAMA 2020, the disposal of substantial company assets, including commercial real estate constituting a significant proportion of company undertaking, requires the explicit approval of shareholders in a general meeting. Any transfer executed by directors in violation of Section 342 is voidable at the instance of the company. Demonstrating non-compliance with this statutory requirement provides conclusive grounds for the court to grant judgment invalidating the transfer and restoring full title to the company.