Filing a petition for relief against unfairly prejudicial conduct concerning redeemable preference shares under CAMA 2020 requires originating a formal company petition at the Federal High Court pursuant to Section 353 and Section 354, demonstrating that the company’s affairs or board actions unfairly disregard or prejudice the rights of the preference shareholder regarding redemption terms, dividend priority, or capital reserves. Under Section 353(1)(a) of CAMA 2020, a holder of redeemable preference shares possesses statutory standing as a registered member of the company entitled to pursue judicial remedies against oppressive and unfairly discriminatory corporate conduct.
Redeemable preference shares represent a hybrid corporate financing instrument granting holders preferential rights to dividends and return of capital ahead of ordinary shareholders, coupled with an obligation or option of redemption by the issuing company. Corporate boards often attempt to bypass redemption obligations or divert capital reserves to benefit ordinary equity holders, triggering statutory legal remedies.
Statutory Rights of Preference Shareholders Under CAMA 2020
The Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 provides rigorous statutory safeguards governing the creation, maintenance, and redemption of preference shares:
- Section 147 Redemption Rules: Redeemable preference shares can only be redeemed out of distributable profits of the company or out of the proceeds of a fresh issue of shares made specifically for the purposes of redemption.
- Capital Redemption Reserve Fund: Under Section 147(4), where shares are redeemed otherwise than out of the proceeds of a fresh issue, a sum equal to the nominal amount of the shares redeemed must be transferred out of profits to a statutory reserve called the Capital Redemption Reserve Fund.
- Protection of Class Rights: Under Section 141 of CAMA 2020, class rights attaching to preference shares cannot be altered, cancelled, or subordinated without the formal sanction of a separate class meeting of preference shareholders.
Grounds for Unfairly Prejudicial Conduct Petitions
To succeed under Section 354 of CAMA 2020, the petitioner must establish that corporate conduct has unfairly prejudiced their interests as a preference shareholder. Actionable grounds include:
- Failure to Honor Redemption Obligations: Refusing to redeem preference shares upon the arrival of a mandatory contractually agreed redemption date, despite the company having sufficient distributable profits or commercial solvency.
- Diversion of Distributable Profits: Paying substantial ordinary dividends or management bonuses while refusing to satisfy cumulative preference dividend arrears.
- Depletion of Redemption Reserves: Unlawfully distributing or eroding the Capital Redemption Reserve Fund through creative accounting restructurings or unapproved capital reductions.
- Prejudicial Restructuring and Subordination: Issuing senior priority debt or creating super-priority equity classes that subordinate the redemption rights of existing preference holders without their statutory consent under Section 141.
Step-by-Step Procedure for Filing the Court Petition
Petitioners must initiate proceedings in the Federal High Court in the judicial division where the company maintains its registered office:
- Originating Company Petition: Draft a formal company petition pursuant to Section 353 of CAMA 2020 and the Companies Proceedings Rules, setting out full particulars of share ownership, issue terms, and specific acts of unfairly prejudicial conduct.
- Affidavit of Verification: Support the petition with an affidavit deposed to by the shareholder or authorized corporate representative, verifying all factual averments.
- Exhibiting Evidentiary Documentation: Attach certified true copies of the Memorandum and Articles of Association, original subscription agreements, share certificates, audited financial statements showing profit reserves, and correspondence demanding redemption.
- Filing and Service on CAC: Under Section 354(2), a copy of the petition must be served on the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) within 14 days of filing, placing the statutory regulator on notice of the corporate dispute.
Judicial Remedies Available Under Section 355 of CAMA 2020
The Federal High Court exercises broad equitable discretion under Section 355 to make any order it deems fit to bring an end to the matters complained of:
- Order for Compulsory Redemption: The court can mandate immediate redemption of the preference shares out of available distributable profits, accompanied by accumulated dividend interest.
- Order for Share Purchase: The court can direct the company or controlling majority shareholders to purchase the petitioner’s preference shares at an independent fair valuation determined by a court-appointed chartered accountant.
- Injunction Against Asset Diversion: The court can issue interim and interlocutory injunctions restraining the board from declaring ordinary dividends, transferring capital assets, or altering corporate capitalization pending final trial.
- Appointment of an Inspector or Administrator: In extreme cases of corporate mismanagement or intentional asset stripping, the court can appoint an independent inspector or an administrator to assume oversight of corporate assets.
Preference shareholders must act promptly upon the occurrence of a redemption default, as unreasonable delay can be construed as acquiescence to prejudicial board conduct.