Rescinding an irregular allotment of shares under the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 requires filing an application for rectification of the register of members before the Federal High Court under Section 115, or instituting an action to set aside the allotment under Section 150 for non-compliance with statutory conditions. Any allotment executed in breach of statutory pre-emptive rights, without general meeting approval, or in violation of corporate authority is voidable at the instance of aggrieved shareholders or the company itself.
The Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 imposes strict safeguards around share capital adjustments to protect existing equity owners from unlawful dilution. When directors issue shares without complying with the provisions of CAMA 2020 or the articles of association, the transaction lacks legal validity and cannot confer lawful ownership upon the recipient.
Common Grounds for Challenging Irregular Share Allotments
An allotment of shares in a Nigerian company can be declared irregular and set aside under several distinct legal circumstances:
- Breach of Statutory Pre-emptive Rights: Section 142 of CAMA 2020 mandates that every newly issued share in both private and public companies must first be offered to existing shareholders in proportion to their current holdings before being offered to third parties.
- Absence of Director Authority: Under Section 149, the fundamental power to allot shares resides in the company in general meeting, although the general meeting may delegate this power to the board through the articles or a general meeting resolution. An allotment executed without valid delegation is ultra vires.
- Issuance Exceeding Share Capital Limits: Directors cannot allot shares beyond the maximum issued share capital registered with the Corporate Affairs Commission without first passing a formal resolution to increase share capital and paying the statutory filing fees.
- Prospectus Misrepresentation: Where shares are issued to the public based on false statements, omissions, or misleading prospectuses, the subscriber has a statutory right to repudiate the agreement and recover all subscription funds.
- Improper Consideration: Issuing shares without valid valuable consideration, or accepting overvalued non-cash assets without statutory independent valuation reports under Section 140, renders the transaction irregular.
Step-by-Step Legal Procedure for Rescission
Aggrieved shareholders or an incoming board seeking to cancel irregular share allocations must follow established procedural steps:
- Notice of Irregularity and Formal Repudiation: An aggrieved subscriber or shareholder must serve a written notice of rescission on the company and the affected allottee within the statutory time limits, formally repudiating the allotment transaction.
- Board Inquiry or General Meeting Resolution: If the current directors discover the irregularity, the board should convene an extraordinary general meeting to formally resolve to challenge the allotment and authorize legal action.
- Filing for Rectification at the Federal High Court: The applicant files an originating summons before the Federal High Court pursuant to Section 115 of CAMA 2020. The court holds exclusive statutory jurisdiction over company matters and has the power to rectify the register of members.
- Interlocutory Injunction: To preserve company stability while the suit is pending, the applicant typically files a motion for an injunction restraining the irregular allottee from voting at general meetings, collecting dividends, or dealing with the shares.
- Court Determination and Order for Cancellation: Upon hearing the merits, if the Federal High Court determines that the allotment violated CAMA 2020, it issues an order striking out the allottee name from the register and directing the refund of any subscription money paid.
- Statutory Filing with the Corporate Affairs Commission: The company secretary must file a certified true copy of the Federal High Court judgment with the Corporate Affairs Commission within fourteen days of the ruling to update the company public file on the Company Registration Portal.
Personal Liabilities of Defaulting Directors
Under Section 150(2) of CAMA 2020, if any director knowingly contravenes or permits the contravention of the statutory rules governing share allotment, that director is personally liable to compensate the company and the allottee for any loss, damages, or legal costs incurred.
Furthermore, directors who allot shares to themselves or their cronies in breach of fiduciary duties can be sued for misfeasance or breach of trust. The court may compel such directors to account for any secret profits, surrender illicit bonuses, and bear the financial burden of restoring the equity structure of the company.