Seeking court sanction or judicial validation for a Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA) under sections 434 to 442 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 (CAMA 2020) requires filing the nominee preliminary report in the Federal High Court, convening statutory meetings of creditors and members, and depositing the certified voting results with the court registrar and the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC). While a standard CVA takes binding legal effect automatically upon filing the approval report, direct court intervention and formal judicial orders are sought where creditors challenge the arrangement or where complementary orders under section 715 schemes are coordinated.
A CVA is a flexible debt reorganization mechanism that allows a distressed corporate debtor to agree on a composition in satisfaction of debts or a deferred payment scheme with its creditors. Governed by Part C of CAMA 2020, the process balances business continuity with creditor protection under the watchful eye of a licensed insolvency practitioner acting as nominee and supervisor.
Step One: Formulating the Proposal and Engaging the Nominee
The initiation of a CVA begins at the corporate governance level before entering the judicial sphere:
- Board Resolution and Proposal Drafting: The directors draft a detailed restructuring proposal setting out proposed debt haircuts, installment schedules, debt-to-equity conversions, and asset disposal programs.
- Nominee Appointment: The company appoints an accredited insolvency practitioner registered with the Business Recovery and Insolvency Practitioners Association of Nigeria (BRIPAN) or recognized professional bodies to act as nominee.
- Nominee Statutory Assessment: The nominee reviews the financial books, verifies asset valuations, and evaluates whether the proposal presents a viable prospect of rescue for the enterprise.
Step Two: Filing the Nominee Report with the Federal High Court
Under section 435(2) of CAMA 2020, the judicial process is triggered by filing the foundational report:
- Deposition in Court: The nominee submits a formal written report to the Federal High Court stating whether, in the opinion of the nominee, the proposed voluntary arrangement has a reasonable prospect of being approved and implemented.
- Summoning Directives: The report specifies the dates, venues, and voting modalities proposed for convening the statutory meetings of company creditors and members.
- Small Company Moratorium: If the debtor qualifies as an eligible small company under the Eleventh Schedule of CAMA 2020, filing the preliminary documents with the court establishes an immediate statutory moratorium shielding the business from hostile winding-up petitions, asset executions, and receivership actions.
Step Three: Conducting Creditors and Members Meetings
The nominee presides over separate statutory meetings to secure creditor and shareholder endorsement:
- Statutory Notices: Issue at least fourteen days written notice to all known creditors and shareholders, enclosing the full proposal, statement of affairs, and nominee assessment.
- Creditor Voting Threshold: Approval requires a statutory majority of not less than 75 percent in value of the unsecured creditors present and voting either in person or by proxy.
- Shareholder Concurrence: A separate meeting of corporate members votes on the restructuring by simple majority of shares represented at the meeting.
- Reconciliation of Discrepancies: Where the creditors and shareholders adopt conflicting resolutions, the decision of the creditors meeting takes legal precedence subject to the right of shareholders to apply to the Federal High Court for relief.
Step Four: Reporting Meeting Outcomes to Court and the Corporate Affairs Commission
Within four days after conducting the statutory meetings, the chairman of the meeting must file a formal return with both the court and the corporate registry:
- Filing with the Federal High Court: Deposit an affidavit and certified minutes indicating whether the proposals were approved unconditionally, approved with modifications, or rejected.
- Registration with CAC: File the statutory CVA returns on the CAC portal to update corporate records and notify the commercial public.
- Commencement of Binding Effect: Once the report is deposited, the CVA binds all unsecured creditors who were entitled to vote, whether or not they received notice or attended the meeting.
Step Five: Judicial Adjudication of Challenges Under Section 439
Where disgruntled creditors challenge the voluntary arrangement, the Federal High Court exercises direct adjudicatory supervision:
- Statutory Grounds for Challenge: A creditor, member, or nominee may apply to the court within twenty-eight days of the report filing on grounds that the arrangement unfairly prejudices creditor interests or that a material irregularity occurred during the voting process.
- Judicial Powers: The court can revoke or suspend the arrangement, order fresh creditors meetings, or give directions for the preservation of corporate assets.
- Supervisory Conclusion: Where no challenge is sustained, the supervisor executes the approved payment plans, filing annual accounts with CAC until complete debt discharge.