Settling an employment dispute with an ex-director in a Nigerian company requires distinguishing between their statutory role as a corporate officer under the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 (CAMA 2020) and their contractual status as an employee under Nigerian labor law. Most executive disputes are resolved through negotiated separation agreements, formal mediation, or adjudication before the National Industrial Court of Nigeria (NICN), which exercises exclusive constitutional jurisdiction over employment and executive contract claims.
When board relationships fracture, companies often commit serious procedural blunders by conflating boardroom removal with employment termination. An executive director holds a dual capacity: a corporate fiduciary appointed by shareholders or the board, and an executive employee employed under a service contract. Mishandling either capacity can expose the company to substantial damages for wrongful dismissal or unfair labor practices.
Understanding the Dual Status of Executive Directors
A proper settlement strategy begins by clarifying the legal basis of the director’s engagement with the corporate entity.
- Statutory Directorship: Section 288 of CAMA 2020 grants a company the unfettered right to remove a director from office by ordinary resolution before the expiration of their term, regardless of anything contained in the company articles or separate agreements.
- Contractual Employment: Section 288(6) explicitly preserves the removed director’s right to claim compensation or damages for breach of any underlying employment or service contract. Removing someone from the board does not automatically terminate their employment contract without legal consequences.
- Managing Directors and C-Suite Executives: Managing directors and chief executive officers typically hold extensive service agreements with specific clauses covering termination notice, golden parachutes, severance packages, intellectual property, and restrictive covenants.
Step-by-Step Approach to Settling Executive Disputes
A structured, methodical approach allows companies to resolve claims amicably while safeguarding confidential proprietary assets and corporate reputation.
- Audit Corporate Records and Employment Contracts: Review the letter of appointment, executive service contract, board minutes, company articles, and employee handbook. Confirm whether the director received adequate statutory notice of removal under Section 288 of CAMA 2020 and contractual notice of termination under their service agreement.
- Assess Financial and Contractual Exposure: Calculate outstanding entitlements, including unpaid salaries, accrued bonuses, untaken leave allowances, share options, pension contributions, and severance pay. Determine whether the company has grounds to assert counterclaims for breach of fiduciary duties or financial mismanagement.
- Initiate Confidential Without-Prejudice Negotiations: Engage the ex-director or their legal counsel in without-prejudice discussions to explore an agreed separation package. Direct executive negotiation avoids public scandal, share price volatility, and disruptive operational distraction.
- Draft a Comprehensive Settlement and Separation Agreement: Formalize the agreed terms in a binding separation deed. The agreement must include clear mutual release clauses, confidentiality covenants, non-disparagement obligations, non-compete restrictions, and timelines for returning company property and intellectual property.
- Address Tax Withholding on Severance Payments: Under the Personal Income Tax Act, genuine compensation for loss of office up to 10,000,000 Naira enjoys specific capital gains tax exemptions, whereas regular terminal benefits remain subject to PAYE deductions. Proper tax structuring prevents disputes with state internal revenue boards.
Resolving Disputes Through Alternative Dispute Resolution
If direct negotiation reaches an impasse, alternative dispute resolution (ADR) offers private, efficient alternatives to public litigation.
- NICN Alternative Dispute Resolution Centre: The National Industrial Court maintains an active ADR Centre where court-accredited mediators assist parties in reaching a consent judgment that is legally binding and enforceable like a regular court decision.
- Commercial Arbitration: Where the executive service agreement contains a valid arbitration clause, disputes must be referred to arbitration in accordance with the Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023. Arbitration offers absolute confidentiality, specialized industry adjudicators, and rapid finality.
- Private Mediation: Parties can retain an independent commercial mediator to broker a structured settlement without commencing court proceedings.
Litigation Risks at the National Industrial Court
When settlement talks fail completely, the dispute proceeds to the National Industrial Court of Nigeria under Section 254C of the 1999 Constitution (as amended).
Nigerian labor jurisprudence has evolved significantly. Under international labor standards applied by the NICN, employers are increasingly required to provide valid reasons connected with capacity or conduct before terminating employment contracts, moving away from common law termination without cause. Ex-directors who demonstrate malicious, humiliating, or unlawful removal frequently secure substantial general and compensatory damages against former employers.
Promptly filing Form CAC 7A (Notice of Change of Directors) with the Corporate Affairs Commission within 14 days of removal is mandatory, but boards should never neglect settling the ex-director’s underlying contractual claims to achieve full legal closure.