Under Principle 16 and Principle 27 of the Nigerian Code of Corporate Governance (NCCG 2018), executive non-compete covenants and garden leave agreements are strictly governed by board remuneration committee oversight, reasonable commercial scope limitations, and transparent reporting in annual corporate filings. While non-compete and garden leave clauses protect proprietary corporate know-how and client goodwill following senior executive exits, Nigerian courts and the NCCG 2018 require that restrictive covenants remain reasonable in duration and geographic scope to avoid acting as an unlawful restraint of trade.
Statutory Principles Under NCCG 2018 and the Common Law Doctrine
Principle 16.7 of the NCCG 2018 mandates that executive termination agreements must balance the legitimate proprietary interests of the enterprise against the individual right to economic livelihood. Under Nigerian labor jurisprudence and common law restraint of trade principles applied by the National Industrial Court of Nigeria (NICN), post-employment restrictive covenants are prima facie void unless the corporate employer proves that the restriction protects a proprietary interest and is reasonable regarding duration, geographic territory, and prohibited activities.
Under Section 279 and Section 305 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA 2020), directors owe continuing fiduciary duties of confidentiality and loyalty that survive their resignation. However, boards cannot enforce overly broad covenants that indefinitely bar executives from participating in their professional sector without providing corresponding remuneration or garden leave pay.
Remuneration Committee Oversight and Garden Leave Mechanics
The NCCG 2018 places primary operational responsibility on the Board Remuneration Committee to structure balanced exit agreements:
- Reasonable Temporal Limits: Non-compete restrictions should typically be capped at six to twelve months following employment termination, with longer durations requiring exceptional justification approved by the board.
- Compensated Garden Leave Structures: Where an executive is placed on garden leave during notice periods, the company must continue paying contractual base salary and preserving essential health benefits while relieving the executive of operational duties.
- Geographic and Sectoral Proportionality: The geographical boundary of the restriction must be strictly confined to markets where the enterprise actively conducts business in Nigeria and West Africa, rather than imposing blanket global bans.
- Remuneration Clawbacks for Non-Compliance: Restrictive agreements must incorporate enforceable clawback covenants empowering the board to reclaim severance payments if the departing executive breaches non-solicitation or confidentiality clauses.
Tax Treatment Under PITA and Statutory Withholding Rules
From a fiscal perspective, payments made to an executive during a garden leave period constitute regular employment earnings subject to Pay-As-You-Earn (PAYE) withholding tax under Section 3 of the Personal Income Tax Act (PITA). The company must deduct PAYE at applicable graduated rates and remit it to the relevant State Internal Revenue Service (SIRS).
Conversely, where a separate lump-sum restrictive covenant consideration is paid explicitly for agreeing to a post-termination non-compete restraint, such consideration is treated as taxable income or capital receipt under tax guidelines. The company must obtain professional tax opinions to ensure proper statutory withholding, avoiding back-duty tax assessments and statutory interest penalties.
Enforcement in the National Industrial Court of Nigeria
When an executive breaches a valid non-compete agreement by joining a direct competitor, the company must seek urgent judicial relief before the National Industrial Court of Nigeria (NICN). Under Section 254C of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended), the NICN has exclusive jurisdiction over labor covenants and restrictive employment disputes.
The court will grant interlocutory injunctions restraining the executive from disclosing proprietary trade secrets, soliciting corporate clients, or joining a rival entity if the company proves that the restrictive covenant was accompanied by fair consideration, reasonable scope, and necessary protection of trade secrets.
Corporate Governance Reporting and Public Disclosures
The board must ensure that all executive non-compete policies and garden leave arrangements are reviewed annually by the governance committee to confirm ongoing alignment with industry norms. Transparent disclosure of restrictive covenant frameworks in the annual corporate governance report mitigates executive litigation risks, enhances investor confidence, and demonstrates authentic compliance with national governance standards.