In corporate liquidation under Nigerian law, a liquidator or the Federal High Court may disallow a creditor’s proof of debt where the underlying claim is statute-barred, lacks credible supporting documentation, arises from an illegal or fraudulent transaction, or constitutes an unliquidated tort claim not provable in winding up. Under Sections 570 to 574 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020 and the Companies Winding-Up Rules, liquidators perform a quasi-judicial function in examining and adjudicating creditor claims.
The Quasi-Judicial Authority of the Liquidator
During insolvency proceedings, whether conducted under court supervision or through a voluntary winding up, the liquidator does not act as a mere administrative clerk. The liquidator functions as an officer of the court vested with quasi-judicial powers to investigate corporate liabilities. Every creditor seeking to participate in asset distributions must file a formal Proof of Debt affidavit verified by statutory declarations and supporting financial vouchers.
The liquidator must review every claim independently to safeguard the liquidation estate. Admitting an invalid claim unlawfully dilutes the dividend pool available to legitimate creditors, exposing the liquidator to personal liability for breach of statutory trust.
Primary Grounds for Disallowing Claims
Liquidators routinely expunge or disallow creditor proofs of debt on established statutory and common law grounds:
- Statute-Barred Liabilities: Under Nigerian limitation statutes, such as the Limitation Law of Lagos State, simple contract debts become legally unenforceable six years after the cause of action accrued. A liquidator cannot admit a claim that was already statute-barred prior to the commencement of winding up, even if former directors acknowledged the debt.
- Lack of Documentary Verification: A proof of debt requires primary substantiating evidence. Claims supported solely by internal ledger entries or disputed invoices without underlying contracts, purchase orders, or signed delivery notes must be disallowed.
- Illegality and Regulatory Infractions: Claims founded on contracts that breach Nigerian statutes are unenforceable. Examples include unapproved foreign exchange transactions violating Central Bank regulations, contracts tainted by corruption, or business activities carried out without mandatory operational licenses.
- Fraudulent and Voidable Preferences: Under Section 658 of CAMA 2020, any transaction executed within the statutory lookback period that confers an unfair preference on a particular creditor while the company is insolvent can be invalidated. Collusive debentures or mortgages granted to company directors shortly before liquidation are routinely rejected.
- Unliquidated Tort Liabilities: Under Nigerian insolvency practice, unliquidated claims sounding in tort, such as unadjudicated claims for negligence or general commercial damages, cannot be proved in liquidation unless they were reduced to a liquidated final court judgment before the commencement of winding up.
Treatment of Post-Liquidation Interest and Currency Conversion
Another frequent ground for partial disallowance involves excessive interest calculations. Creditors often claim ongoing contractual interest running past the date of the winding-up order. Under Nigerian insolvency rules, interest stops accruing on unsecured debts upon the commencement of winding up unless the company turns out to be fully solvent and all principal debts are satisfied in full.
Where claims are denominated in foreign currencies, liquidators must disallow exchange rates applied after the liquidation commencement date. Debts must be converted to Nigerian Naira at the official Central Bank of Nigeria exchange rate prevailing on the date the winding-up order was made, preventing opportunistic currency speculation from distorting creditor recovery pools.
The Formal Notice of Rejection Procedure
When a liquidator determines that a proof of debt should be disallowed wholly or in part, procedural fairness requires formal communication. The liquidator must issue a written Notice of Rejection of Proof to the creditor, setting out the factual and legal reasons for the disallowance.
The notice informs the creditor of their statutory right to appeal. Under the Companies Winding-Up Rules, an aggrieved claimant has 21 days from the date of service of the rejection notice to file an application before the Federal High Court seeking an order to reverse or modify the liquidator’s decision.
Judicial Review at the Federal High Court
When an appeal reaches the Federal High Court, the court conducts a complete re-hearing of the claim. The judge examines whether the liquidator applied proper legal standards and whether the underlying commercial transactions were authentic. If the court finds that the liquidator acted properly, the rejection is affirmed, and the claimant is barred from participating in dividend distributions from the company’s realized assets.