Under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, a director who breaches the statutory duty to avoid or disclose a conflict of interest faces severe civil and regulatory liabilities. These consequences include the rescission of any tainted transaction, mandatory disgorgement of secret profits, personal liability to indemnify the company for resulting financial losses, and prospective disqualification from serving as a corporate director in Nigeria.
Directors occupy a fiduciary position that demands utmost loyalty, good faith, and accountability toward the company. Section 305 and Section 306 of CAMA 2020 explicitly codify these fiduciary duties, establishing that a director cannot place their personal interests in conflict with their official duties to the corporate entity.
Statutory Framework Governing Director Conflicts
The statutory benchmark under Section 306(1) of CAMA 2020 imposes an affirmative duty on every director to avoid situations where they have, or can have, a direct or indirect interest that conflicts with the interests of the company. This obligation applies to the exploitation of corporate property, corporate opportunities, or business information acquired through their position, even after resigning as a director.
Section 307 further obligates a director who is in any way, directly or indirectly, interested in a transaction, contract, or proposed arrangement with the company to declare the nature and extent of that interest at a meeting of the board of directors. Failure to disclose strips the director of any legal defense when an enforcement action is initiated.
Primary Legal Consequences and Remedies for Breach
When an unapproved or undisclosed conflict of interest occurs, Nigerian company law provides several robust legal remedies enforceable by the company, liquidators, or aggrieved shareholders:
- Rescission of Contracts: Any commercial transaction or contract concluded where an undisclosed conflict existed is voidable at the instance of the company. The company can apply to court to set aside the contract, restoring both parties to their pre-transaction positions.
- Account of Profits and Disgorgement: A director must hold all profits, commissions, or economic benefits acquired from the conflicted transaction as a constructive trustee for the company. The company can compel full accounting and legal disgorgement of every Naira gained.
- Equitable Compensation and Damages: If the company sustained direct losses, asset depreciation, or lost commercial gains due to the director self-dealing, the director is personally liable to pay comprehensive equitable compensation.
- Removal from Office: Under Section 288 of CAMA 2020, shareholders can remove a defaulting director by passing an ordinary resolution in a general meeting, irrespective of any contractual employment agreements.
- Disqualification under Section 280: The Corporate Affairs Commission or the Federal High Court can bar the defaulting individual from holding board positions or acting as a corporate insolvency practitioner for up to ten years.
- Statutory Administrative Fines: CAMA 2020 empowers the CAC to impose daily administrative penalties on defaulting directors who fail to disclose statutory board interests.
Direct versus Indirect Conflict of Interest
Nigerian corporate jurisprudence recognizes two primary categories of conflict that trigger statutory liability:
- Direct Conflicts: Arise when a director enters into a commercial contract personally with the company, such as selling personal property, intellectual assets, or commercial real estate directly to the company without independent valuation and board approval.
- Indirect Conflicts: Occur when the commercial counterparty is a corporate entity where the director holds equity, a partnership in which the director is a partner, or a trust benefiting the director close family members. The disclosure obligation applies equally to these related-party dealings.
Corporate Governance Measures to Mitigate Liability
Corporate boards in Nigeria must institute formal compliance mechanisms to prevent inadvertent breaches. Every company should maintain an active Register of Directors Interests that is updated quarterly. Directors must formally recuse themselves from board deliberations and voting whenever related-party transactions are considered.
Furthermore, under Section 306(3) of CAMA 2020, a director can shield themselves from liability by seeking formal ratification. If the director makes full, honest, and comprehensive disclosure of the conflict to the general meeting, the shareholders may pass a resolution ratifying the transaction, provided the conduct did not involve fraud on minority shareholders.