Under Nigerian maritime law, cargo owners whose heavy machinery is jettisoned or damaged due to deck lashing failure have enforceable legal remedies under the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, the Admiralty Jurisdiction Act 1991, and common law bailment principles. The cargo owner or designated underwriter can institute an action in rem before the Federal High Court to arrest the carrying vessel, obtain security for the claim, and recover financial compensation for breach of the carrier non-delegable duty of seaworthiness.
Heavy machinery stowed on ship weather decks presents severe structural and hydrodynamic risks. If a carrier fails to supply certified twist-locks, lashing chains, tensioners, and load calculation plans, and the vessel encounters ordinary heavy weather, the carrier cannot hide behind statutory maritime peril exemptions to justify jettisoning cargo.
Carrier Obligations and Seaworthiness Under Nigerian Law
The Hague Rules and Hague-Visby Rules incorporated into Nigerian domestic legislation impose strict duties on maritime carriers:
- Non-Delegable Duty of Seaworthiness: Article III Rule 1 of the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act mandates that the carrier must exercise due diligence before and at the beginning of the voyage to make the ship seaworthy, properly equip her, and make the holds and decks fit for carriage.
- Proper Loading and Lashing Care: Article III Rule 2 requires the carrier to properly and carefully load, handle, stow, carry, keep, care for, and discharge the goods carried. Stowage of heavy machinery on deck requires specialized lashing calculated against roll and pitch acceleration forces.
- Deck Stowage Authorization: Carriage of cargo on deck without an express deck stowage agreement in the bill of lading constitutes an impermissible deviation, voiding contractual limitations of carrier liability.
Challenging Improper General Average Jettison Claims
Carriers frequently declare General Average following machinery jettison, demanding that cargo owners contribute to the common sacrifice. Under the York-Antwerp Rules recognized in Nigerian maritime practice, General Average applies only when a sacrifice is intentionally and reasonably made for the common safety during a real maritime peril.
If the jettison was necessitated by the carrier own actionable negligence, defective deck lashing cables, or improper weight distribution, the cargo owner is entitled to resist General Average contributions. Nigerian courts uphold the rule that a carrier cannot claim General Average contribution for an emergency created by its own initial failure to exercise due diligence to ensure seaworthiness.
Procedural Steps for Pursuing Legal Remedies in Nigeria
- Issue Prompt Notice of Loss: Deliver immediate formal notice of damage or cargo loss in writing to the carrier, ship master, and local shipping agency within statutory time limits upon vessel arrival at Nigerian ports.
- Appoint Certified Marine Cargo Surveyors: Commission an independent marine engineer or cargo surveyor to inspect the deck securing points, examine broken D-rings and lashing turnbuckles, and calculate dynamic stress levels.
- File Action in Rem in the Federal High Court: Institute admiralty proceedings invoking the exclusive maritime jurisdiction of the Federal High Court under Section 1 and Section 2 of the Admiralty Jurisdiction Act 1991.
- Apply for Warrant of Arrest Against the Vessel: File an ex parte application for a ship arrest warrant, preventing the vessel from departing Nigerian territorial waters until the shipowner provides adequate bank security or a recognized P&I Club Letter of Undertaking.
- Prosecute Subrogated Insurance and Damage Claims: Litigate or negotiate settlement for the full replacement value of the heavy machinery, offshore crane components, or industrial excavators jettisoned at sea.
Limitation of Liability and Exceptions
Carriers often attempt to invoke statutory package limitations under the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act. However, where the claimant demonstrates that deck stowage was unauthorized, or that the loss resulted from an act or omission done with intent to cause damage or recklessly and with knowledge that damage would probably result, the carrier loses the right to limit financial liability under maritime law.



