Under Section 85 and Section 86 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020, a company possesses four primary legal remedies against a promoter who makes secret profits or breaches fiduciary duty: rescission of the underlying transaction, an action for an account of profits, a civil claim for damages for breach of duty or fraud, and recovery of the illicit gain under constructive trust principles. Promoters stand in a strict fiduciary relationship towards the company they establish and owe it uncompromised loyalty, utmost good faith, and complete disclosure.
A promoter is defined under Section 85 as any person who undertakes to take part in forming a company with reference to a given project and to set it going, or who takes part in its management before actual incorporation. Because the future company has no voice of its own during pre-incorporation negotiations, the law holds the promoter to the highest ethical and fiduciary standard.
The Nature of a Promoter Fiduciary Duty
The fiduciary status of a promoter imposes specific legal obligations that cannot be evaded through clever contractual drafting:
- Duty of Utmost Good Faith: The promoter must act strictly in the prospective company best commercial interests and avoid conflicts of interest between personal gain and corporate welfare.
- Duty of Full and Frank Disclosure: Any property sold, leased, or transferred to the newly formed company by the promoter, or any commission received from third parties, must be fully disclosed to an independent board of directors or to all incoming shareholders.
- Prohibition of Secret Gains: Any financial gain, markup, or kickback pocketed by the promoter without express corporate knowledge and independent shareholder approval constitutes an illegal secret profit.
Statutory Remedies Available to the Company
Where a promoter breaches fiduciary duties or conceals personal profits, CAMA 2020 empowers the company to pursue structured legal remedies before the Federal High Court:
- Rescission of the Contract: Under Section 86(1), the company may rescind the transaction entered into with the promoter. Rescission restores both parties to their pre-contractual positions, returning the asset to the promoter and refunding the company purchase funds. Rescission is available provided the company acts promptly upon discovering the fraud and third party rights have not intervened.
- Account of Profits: If rescission is impractical because the property has been altered, consumed, or transferred to innocent third parties, the company can compel the promoter to account for and surrender all unauthorized financial gains. The promoter must forfeit the entire profit margin regardless of whether the company suffered direct financial loss.
- Action for Damages or Compensation: Where the promoter engaged in fraudulent misrepresentation or willful concealment of market values, the company can sue for damages in deceit. The court will order the promoter to compensate the corporate entity for all losses resulting from the overvaluation.
- Constructive Trust and Asset Tracing: In equity, a promoter who acquires property while acting for an intended company holds that property or the proceeds of resale as a constructive trustee for the company. The company can trace the misappropriated funds into bank accounts, real estate, or other investments purchased with the illicit money.
Corporate Enforcement and Minority Shareholder Action
In many corporate disputes, the defaulting promoters also sit as controlling directors and majority shareholders of the newly incorporated company, creating an enforcement deadlock. Under the traditional common law rule in Foss v Harbottle, the company is the proper plaintiff to sue for corporate wrongs.
However, CAMA 2020 eliminates this obstacle through statutory minority protection mechanisms. Under Section 343 and Section 344, aggrieved minority shareholders can apply to the Federal High Court for leave to bring a derivative action in the name and on behalf of the company against the defaulting promoters. The court will grant leave where it is demonstrated that the promoters control the board and are using their voting power to stifle corporate recovery, ensuring that breach of promoter duties never escapes judicial accountability.