Under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, the statutory function of a liquidator in distributing surplus assets is to realize and allocate remaining corporate property strictly in accordance with the rights attached to respective share classes after all winding-up costs, preferential debts, and unsecured creditor claims have been fully discharged. The liquidator acts as a court-appointed or member-appointed statutory fiduciary who must distribute the net surplus among members rateably unless the Articles of Association establish specific preferential entitlements.
Statutory Priorities Preceding Surplus Distribution
Surplus assets only come into existence when the liquidation estate generates funds exceeding total corporate liabilities. Section 657 of CAMA 2020 outlines an unyielding hierarchy of payments that the liquidator must satisfy prior to considering any distribution to equity contributors.
The liquidator must first settle the expenses properly incurred in the winding up, including liquidator remuneration, legal costs, and auctioneer fees. Next, preferential debts such as accrued employee wages, accrued holiday remuneration, statutory pension contributions, and local rates or taxes must be paid. Following preferential debts, floating charge holders and ordinary unsecured trade creditors are paid. Only when all debts are settled with statutory interest does any residual fund qualify as surplus assets.
Step-by-Step Procedure for Distributing Surplus Assets
The liquidator must follow a systematic legal sequence to effect an unassailable distribution of surplus capital:
- Prepare Detailed Realization and Liquidation Accounts: The liquidator drafts comprehensive accounts showing all asset realizations, interest earned on deposits, costs deducted, and creditor claims settled. These accounts must undergo formal auditing.
- Analyze the Articles of Association: Examine the corporate constitution to decipher the precise rights attached to each class of shares. The liquidator must verify whether preference shares carry a right to participate in surplus assets or are strictly confined to return of nominal capital.
- Equalize Capital Contributions Among Members: Where shares of the same class were issued with unequal amounts paid up, the liquidator must equalize the position among contributories. This is achieved by first repaying capital to those who paid more, or making a nominal equalization call on partly paid shares before declaring surplus dividends.
- Obtain Regulatory Tax Clearances: Secure formal clearance letters from the Federal Inland Revenue Service (now Nigeria Revenue Service) and relevant State Internal Revenue Services confirming that all corporate tax liabilities and capital gains taxes arising from asset sales have been cleared.
- Execute Cash or In-Specie Distribution: Distribute the net proceeds rateably in cash to registered members. Where the Articles or an extraordinary resolution allows, the liquidator may distribute physical assets or investment securities in specie, provided independent valuations support the allocation.
- Convene Final Meetings and File with CAC: Summon the final meeting of the company by publishing notice in the Federal Government Gazette and two national daily newspapers. Submit the final return and statement of accounts to the Corporate Affairs Commission within seven days of the meeting.
Treatment of Different Share Classes and Unclaimed Funds
The liquidator must strictly observe specific legal rules when apportioning surplus funds among diverse claimants:
- Ordinary Shares: Ordinary shareholders hold the primary equity risk and are entitled to divide all ultimate surplus assets rateably according to nominal shareholding percentages.
- Preference Shares: Unless the Articles of Association expressly grant a right to participate in residual profits, preference shareholders are legally presumed to have no claim on surplus assets once their capital and fixed preferential dividends are repaid.
- Contributory Rights: If a past member has liability under Section 572 of CAMA 2020, their outstanding liability must be set off prior to receiving any distribution from the surplus estate.
- Unclaimed Dividends: Any surplus asset money remaining unclaimed by untraceable shareholders after six months must be paid immediately into the Companies Liquidation Account maintained by the CAC or Central Bank of Nigeria.
Personal Fiduciary Liability of the Liquidator
A liquidator who distributes corporate funds to shareholders prematurely before resolving disputed creditor claims or tax liabilities commits misfeasance under Section 673 of CAMA 2020. The Federal High Court holds the liquidator personally liable to make good the disbursed sums, reinforcing the absolute necessity of strict statutory compliance.