Under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, the Federal High Court possesses statutory authority to review, invalidate, or set aside unfair asset dispositions conducted by a liquidator upon the application of an aggrieved creditor, contributory, or subsequent liquidator. While liquidators enjoy broad administrative discretion in realizing company property, the court will intervene when an asset sale demonstrates bad faith, collusive undervalue, conflict of interest, or breach of statutory insolvency controls.
The Supervisory Jurisdiction of the Federal High Court Under CAMA 2020
Section 588 and Section 590 of CAMA 2020 outline the general powers and duties of liquidators in both court-ordered and voluntary winding up. Although a liquidator has the power to sell the real and personal property of the company by public auction or private treaty, this power is held in a fiduciary capacity for the benefit of the general body of creditors and contributories.
Under Section 591 of CAMA 2020, any person aggrieved by any act or decision of the liquidator may apply to the Federal High Court, and the court may confirm, reverse, or modify the act or decision complained of, and make such order in the premises as it thinks just. This provision provides the primary statutory mechanism to challenge an improper disposal of corporate property.
Statutory Grounds for Setting Aside Liquidator Dispositions
Nigerian courts maintain the traditional principle that judges should not lightly interfere with a liquidator commercial discretion. However, an asset disposition will be set aside under four well-defined statutory grounds:
- Transactions at an Undervalue: Under Section 659 of CAMA 2020, where a disposition of company assets is concluded for a consideration significantly lower than fair market value without independent certified valuation reports, the court will intervene to prevent asset dissipation.
- Fraudulent or Unfair Preferences: Under Section 658 of CAMA 2020, any conveyance, mortgage, or delivery of assets made with the intention of placing a preferred creditor or connected person in a better position than the general class of unsecured creditors is invalid.
- Conflict of Interest and Self-Dealing: A liquidator occupies a strict fiduciary position. If an asset is transferred directly or indirectly to the liquidator, their family members, partners, professional firms, or associated companies without prior disclosure and explicit court sanction, the sale will be rescinded as constructive fraud.
- Absence of Mandatory Approvals: Where the company articles, a court order, or Section 588 requires the sanction of the committee of inspection or the court before selling specialized assets, a unilateral private treaty sale by the liquidator is ultra vires and voidable.
Procedural Steps for Filing a Challenge in Court
Aggrieved creditors or shareholders challenging an unfair disposition must execute a methodical legal strategy:
- Originating Process: File an application by way of motion or originating summons before the Federal High Court within the judicial division where the liquidation is pending.
- Supporting Affidavit Evidence: Provide comprehensive affidavit evidence including independent real estate or machinery appraisals, proof of higher bona fide third-party bids that were rejected, and records showing procedural irregularities.
- Joinder of the Asset Purchaser: Join both the liquidator and the third-party asset buyer to the suit, demonstrating that the purchaser either had constructive notice of the undervalue or acted in collusion with the liquidator.
- Interim Protective Injunction: Secure an urgent interim order restraining the buyer from dissipating, transferring, mortgaging, or developing the subject property pending determination of the substantive application.
Remedies and Judicial Orders Available to the Court
When the Federal High Court finds that an asset disposition was unfair, collusive, or legally defective, it can grant several potent remedies under CAMA 2020:
- Order Rescinding the Sale: Setting aside the conveyance or deed of transfer and directing the land registry or relevant asset registry to cancel registrations.
- Order for Restitution of Assets: Directing the buyer to yield vacant possession and surrender original title documents back to the company liquidation estate.
- Surcharge and Personal Liability: Under Section 665 of CAMA 2020, assessing damages against the delinquent liquidator and ordering personal financial compensation to make good the financial deficit suffered by the estate.
- Removal and Replacement of the Liquidator: Removing the liquidator for cause due to misconduct or unfitness and appointing an independent insolvency practitioner accredited by the CAC.