Under Section 662 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, a liquidator has statutory authority to disclaim onerous property, unprofitable contracts, and unexpired real property leases held by a company in liquidation, subject to obtaining the leave of the court or the committee of inspection. The disclaimer operates to determine, from the date of the disclaimer, the rights, interests, and liabilities of the company in respect of the property disclaimed, while allowing affected counterparties and landlords to prove in the winding-up as unsecured creditors for resulting financial injuries.
When a corporate entity enters formal liquidation in Nigeria, the primary statutory objective of the liquidator is to collect, realize, and distribute company assets equitably among creditors. In many insolvencies, the insolvent estate is weighed down by burdensome legacy commitments such as long-term commercial real estate leases with prohibitive rental obligations, onerous service contracts, or shares subject to pending financial calls. Forcing the liquidator to perform these commitments would drain the remaining cash reserves, harming the general body of unsecured creditors.
Qualifying Categories of Disclaimable Property
Section 662(1) of CAMA 2020 defines the categories of corporate property that qualify for statutory disclaimer during formal winding-up proceedings:
- Land Burdened with Onerous Covenants: Real property held by the company that requires ongoing capital expenditure, environmental remediation liabilities, or onerous development covenants that exceed the commercial value of the land.
- Shares Carrying Unpaid Calls: Equity or stocks in other corporate bodies where outstanding call liabilities exist that would expose the liquidation estate to financial demands.
- Unprofitable Contracts: Commercial executory contracts where the cost of completing performance exceeds any anticipated economic consideration or benefit to the liquidation estate.
- Long-Term Property Leases: Commercial premises leases carrying above-market rent covenants, aggressive service charges, or dilapidation repair obligations that serve no utility for winding-up operations.
Statutory Procedure and Time Limits
The right of disclaimer is governed by strict statutory procedures to prevent liquidators from stringing counterparties along indefinitely:
- General Twelve-Month Window: The liquidator must disclaim the burdensome property in writing within twelve months after the commencement of the winding-up. If the liquidator was not aware of the property within one month of appointment, the twelve-month period begins from the date the property was first discovered.
- The Twenty-Eight Day Notice Mechanism: Any counterparty, landlord, or interested party can serve a formal written notice on the liquidator requiring a definitive election. The liquidator must apply to court or execute the disclaimer within twenty-eight days of receiving this notice; failure to do so strips the liquidator of the statutory power to disclaim, making the contract or lease binding on the estate.
- Leave of the Federal High Court: Disclaiming an unexpired lease requires leave of the court under Section 662(3), unless general rules permit otherwise. The court balances the rights of the landlord, sub-tenants, and creditors before granting leave.
- Written Disclaimer Execution: The disclaimer must be formally drawn, signed by the liquidator under hand, and served directly on all interested parties, including landlords, mortgagees, and contracting partners.
Legal Consequences for Landlords and Counterparties
The execution of a valid disclaimer has specific legal consequences. It terminates all rights, interests, and liabilities of the insolvent company in the disclaimed asset from the effective date of the instrument. However, the disclaimer does not affect the rights or liabilities of any other person, except so far as is necessary for the purpose of releasing the company and its property from liability.
A landlord cannot demand post-disclaimer rent as an administrative expense of the winding-up. Instead, under Section 662(7) of CAMA 2020, any person injured by the operation of a disclaimer is deemed to be a creditor of the company to the amount of the injury, and may accordingly prove the amount as a debt in the winding-up. The landlord calculates the contractual loss representing future rent less the current open-market rental value of the returned premises over the remaining term.
Court Vesting Orders and Sub-Tenant Protections
To prevent arbitrary injustice against innocent third parties, Section 662(6) empowers the Federal High Court to make vesting orders upon application by any person claiming an interest in the disclaimed property, such as a lawful sub-tenant or a commercial mortgagee. The court may vest the disclaimed leasehold directly in the sub-tenant, subject to the same covenants and liabilities that bound the insolvent tenant, ensuring that business premises are not abruptly forfeited without adequate recourse.