Under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, an appointed liquidator acts as an agent of the insolvent company and does not assume personal liability for pre-existing corporate leases, rent arrears, or ongoing tenant covenants. However, this statutory shield is conditional: to prevent post-liquidation rent from becoming an expense of the winding up and to protect against claims of personal misfeasance, the liquidator must timely execute the statutory power of disclaimer under Section 663 of CAMA 2020.
When a corporate tenant enters court-ordered or voluntary winding up, legal title to leasehold property remains vested in the corporate body rather than transferring automatically to the liquidator. Consequently, commercial landlords cannot directly levy execution against the personal estate or assets of the insolvency practitioner, provided the practitioner follows statutory procedures and avoids personal contractual novation.
The Statutory Disclaimer Mechanism Under Section 663 of CAMA 2020
The primary statutory mechanism shielding the liquidation estate and clarifying liabilities is the disclaimer of onerous property under Section 663 of CAMA 2020:
- Scope of Disclaimer: Where any part of the property of a company consists of land burdened with onerous covenants, unprofitable contracts, or unsaleable assets, the liquidator may disclaim the property in writing, notwithstanding having endeavored to sell or taken possession of it.
- Statutory Time Limits: The liquidator must execute the disclaimer within twelve months after the commencement of winding up, or such extended period as the Federal High Court may permit.
- Landlord 28-Day Notice Procedure: If an affected landlord delivers a formal written application requiring the liquidator to decide whether to disclaim, the liquidator must respond within 28 days. Failure to disclaim within this statutory window bars the liquidator from disclaiming without leave of court, thereby elevating subsequent rent claims.
- Legal Effect of Disclaimer: Disclaimer operates to determine, from the date of execution, the rights, interests, and liabilities of the insolvent company in respect of the leasehold. It releases the company from ongoing rent obligations but leaves the landlord entitled to prove for damages as an unsecured creditor under Section 663(7).
Corporate Estate Expenses Versus Personal Liability of the Liquidator
Understanding when lease liabilities attach to the insolvency estate versus the practitioner personally requires careful legal distinction:
- Rent as a Liquidation Expense: Under the established Lundy Granite principle applicable in Nigerian insolvency jurisprudence, if a liquidator retains physical possession of leased premises for the convenience, benefit, or profit of the liquidation (such as conducting an auction of machinery), rent accrued during that specific period ranks as an administrative expense paid in priority from corporate assets.
- Personal Indemnity Protection: Even where rent ranks as a priority liquidation expense, the liability rests on the insolvent corporate funds, not the personal purse of the liquidator, unless the liquidator signed personal undertakings or acted outside statutory powers.
- Exceptions Incurring Personal Liability: A liquidator loses personal immunity if they commit personal trespass, commit waste, execute a new tenancy agreement in their individual name, or act fraudulently and in breach of fiduciary duties under Section 565 of CAMA 2020.
Judicial Supervision and Landlord Protection Under Nigerian Law
Landlords aggrieved by an insolvent company’s lease termination are not left without statutory protection. Under Section 663(6) of CAMA 2020, any person claiming an interest in disclaimed property can apply to the Federal High Court for a vesting order transferring the property to them or another qualifying party.
Moreover, landlords holding unpaid rent accrued prior to the winding-up order must submit formal proof of debt to the liquidator. Such arrears rank as ordinary unsecured claims that participate rateably in dividend distributions after preferential creditors (such as employee wages and statutory taxes) are satisfied.
Practical Best Practices for Nigerian Insolvency Practitioners
To insulate themselves from litigation and personal liability, liquidators handling leased premises should adopt four systematic steps:
- Conduct an Immediate Lease Audit: Review all outstanding tenancy agreements within seven days of appointment to identify onerous covenants, dilapidation claims, and rent structures.
- Issue Prompt Non-Adoption Notices: Formally notify landlords in writing that the liquidator does not assume personal liability and that occupancy is strictly temporary for inventory reconciliation.
- Execute Statutory Disclaimers Within 28 Days: Promptly draft, sign, and deliver notices of disclaimer for non-viable industrial or commercial premises before statutory windows close.
- Maintain Segregated Escrow Accounts: If retaining premises to sell inventory, set aside estimated occupation rent as an administrative liquidation expense to satisfy legitimate landlord claims without dispute.