The legal difference between nominal value and market value of shares in Nigeria lies in statutory definition versus commercial pricing: nominal value, also known as par value, is the fixed minimum face value assigned to each share in a company constitution, while market value is the actual commercial price that a willing buyer pays a willing seller for that share based on corporate financial performance, asset backing, and prevailing economic conditions.
Under Section 146 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, shares issued by Nigerian companies must possess a nominal value expressed in Nigerian currency. However, the commercial worth of those shares often diverges substantially from their nominal benchmark as the business generates assets, incurs debt, or builds market reputation.
Core Distinctions Between Nominal and Market Value
The distinction between these two valuation concepts governs corporate accounting, tax computations, and capital raising under Nigerian corporate law.
- Source of Valuation: Nominal value is an arbitrary base amount chosen by company promoters upon incorporation or subsequent share capital restructuring, such as 1 Naira per share. Market value is determined by objective financial metrics, audited earnings, discounted cash flows, or secondary market trading on exchanges such as the Nigerian Exchange (NGX) or NASD OTC Securities Exchange.
- Statutory Capital Accounting: The nominal value forms the legal foundation of the issued share capital of the company. It represents the permanent capital cushion committed to company creditors. Market value has no direct reflection in the registered share capital figure filed at the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC).
- Share Premium Application: When shares are issued to new investors at a price higher than their nominal value, the excess amount constitutes a share premium under Section 145 of CAMA 2020. This surplus must be placed into a separate share premium account, which is subject to specific statutory capital preservation restrictions.
- Discount Restrictions: Nigerian law prohibits companies from issuing shares at a discount below their nominal value except under stringent statutory conditions and regulatory approvals. In contrast, market value can legally trade below or above nominal value based on investor perception and distressed circumstances.
- Taxation and Transaction Duties: Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) stamp duties and CAC regulatory fees for company registration or capital increases are assessed strictly on nominal share capital. Conversely, Capital Gains Tax (CGT) administered under Nigerian tax legislation is computed on the actual market consideration paid during a share transfer.
Step-by-Step Procedure for Issuing Shares Above Nominal Value
When a private limited company in Nigeria expands its investor base, incoming investors rarely acquire equity at the original par value. Directors and existing shareholders must execute a clear corporate procedure to document the transaction legitimately.
- Obtain Professional Valuation: Commission an independent chartered accountant or licensed valuation specialist to appraise the fair market value of company equity using recognized methodologies such as net asset valuation or earnings multiples.
- Convene Board and General Meetings: The board of directors must draft an allotment proposal setting out the total shares to be issued, the nominal base price, and the negotiated share premium. The shareholders must then pass an ordinary resolution authorizing the directors to allot the unissued shares at the agreed market valuation.
- Execute Share Subscription Agreement: The company and the subscriber must execute a formal subscription agreement specifying the dual components of the purchase price, clearly dividing the total investment into nominal share value and capital premium.
- Receive Funds and Record Capital Allocations: The company receives the subscription proceeds into its corporate account. The finance team credits the nominal portion to the issued share capital account and the remaining balance to the statutory share premium account.
- File Return of Allotment with CAC: Within one month of the transaction, the company must file a Return of Allotment (Form CAC 2A) on the CAC Company Registration Portal. The filing must disclose the number of shares allotted, nominal value, consideration paid, and personal details of the new shareholder.
- Issue Digital Share Certificates: The company updates its internal Register of Members and issues an official share certificate to the incoming shareholder stating the number of shares held and the nominal denomination.
Practical Implications for Share Transfers and Buyouts
During private equity acquisitions or founder exits, parties frequently confuse nominal figures with transfer values. If a founder owns 500,000 shares of 1 Naira nominal value, the corporate registry records nominal equity of 500,000 Naira.
If the business is worth 100 million Naira, the real transfer price will reflect that commercial worth rather than the historical 1 Naira face value. The deed of share transfer and accompanying stamp duty assessment must clearly reflect the actual market consideration exchanged between parties to avoid tax evasion disputes with revenue authorities.