A foreign company can enforce an arbitral award against a state government in Nigeria under the Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023 (AMA 2023) or the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, commonly known as the New York Convention. However, enforcing an award against a subnational government requires strict compliance with statutory pre-conditions, most notably surmounting the legal barrier created by Section 84 of the Sheriffs and Civil Process Act, which mandates obtaining the prior consent of the state Attorney General before attaching state funds.
Foreign investors frequently enter into joint venture arrangements, infrastructure concessions, and public-private partnerships with Nigerian subnational governments. When contractual disputes arise and an international arbitral tribunal renders a monetary award in favor of the foreign entity, converting that award into real assets requires a structured judicial procedure within the Nigerian court system.
Statutory Basis for Recognizing Foreign Arbitral Awards
Nigeria acceded to the New York Convention in 1970 subject to the commercial and reciprocity reservations. The Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023 reinforces this framework under Section 57, granting the Federal High Court and State High Courts jurisdiction to recognize and enforce foreign arbitral awards irrespective of the country in which the award was made.
To initiate enforcement, the foreign judgment creditor files an originating motion or originating summons supported by an affidavit setting out the dispute history. The applicant must furnish three essential statutory exhibits:
- The duly authenticated original arbitral award or a certified true copy of the final award.
- The original arbitration agreement or a certified copy containing the dispute resolution clause.
- A certified English translation of the award if the arbitral proceedings were conducted in a foreign language.
Commercial Exception to Sovereign and State Immunity
When faced with enforcement proceedings, Nigerian state governments regularly invoke sovereign immunity from suit. Under Nigerian jurisprudence, courts draw a clear dividing line between sovereign governmental actions and commercial transactions:
- Commercial Acts: When a state government enters into a purely commercial contract, such as procurement of goods, agricultural concessions, or facility construction, it operates in the private marketplace. By executing an arbitration agreement, the state waives immunity from jurisdiction.
- Sovereign Acts: Where state activity directly involves public administration, defense, or executive policy, sovereign immunity doctrines apply with greater force.
Nigerian appellate courts have repeatedly affirmed that subnational entities cannot sign commercial contracts containing binding arbitration agreements and subsequently seek shelter behind sovereign immunity to defeat the resulting award.
The Section 84 Sheriffs and Civil Process Act Hurdle
While obtaining a judicial order recognizing the arbitral award as a judgment of the High Court is relatively accessible, executing monetary recovery against state treasury accounts presents substantial friction. Section 84 of the Sheriffs and Civil Process Act stipulates that money held in the custody of a public officer cannot be attached via garnishee proceedings without first securing the consent of the appropriate Attorney General.
In practice, state Attorneys General rarely consent to garnishee proceedings against their own government treasuries. Consequently, foreign award creditors must adopt deliberate enforcement pathways:
- Constitutional Challenges: Creditors have challenged Section 84 before appellate courts, arguing that conditioning court execution on an adverse party consent violates constitutional access to justice and fair hearing rights. Recent Supreme Court pronouncements show varying views, with some panels upholding the requirement as a safeguard against freezing essential public revenue, while others criticize using the section to frustrate valid judgments.
- Commercial Bank Custody Arguments: Creditors frequently argue that commercial banks holding state deposits are not public officers, meaning ordinary bank balances do not fall strictly within the protective cloak of Section 84.
- Attachment of Commercial Assets: Award creditors may seek charging orders against commercial, non-public assets owned by state investment corporations or state-owned commercial entities rather than general government bank accounts.
- Offshore Enforcement: Where the Nigerian state government maintains commercial assets, bank balances, or properties in foreign jurisdictions such as the United Kingdom or the United States, creditors can register the award in those foreign courts under local state immunity statutes that contain robust commercial exceptions.
Grounds for Refusal of Recognition Under AMA 2023
A Nigerian state government resisting enforcement can rely only on the narrow grounds specified in Section 58 of the AMA 2023. These statutory grounds include establishing that a party lacked legal capacity, that the arbitration agreement was invalid under governing law, that the state was denied proper notice of the proceedings, that the dispute was non-arbitrable under Nigerian law, or that enforcement violates Nigerian public policy.



