Beneficiaries of an Employee Share Ownership Scheme (ESOP) trust can challenge an unlawful unilateral cancellation by corporate directors by instituting an action for unfair prejudice and breach of trust at the Federal High Court under Sections 343 to 346 and Section 305 of CAMA 2020. Aggrieved employee-participants can seek interlocutory injunctions to freeze trust share transfers, obtain declaratory relief nullifying the directors’ board resolution, and compel the reconstitution of trust assets in accordance with the registered Trust Deed and Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) guidelines.
Employee Share Ownership Schemes are structured either through direct share allocations or via dedicated Employee Share Trusts holding ordinary shares for vesting among eligible staff. When company directors attempt to unilaterally revoke, cancel, or re-absorb ESOP trust shares back into corporate treasury without beneficiary consent or trust deed authority, they commit actionable legal breaches under both trust law and corporate statutory regimes.
Statutory Bases Under CAMA 2020 and Trust Law
Aggrieved employees possess robust statutory standing under Nigerian corporate law to litigate unauthorized tampering with ESOP structures:
- Breach of Fiduciary Duties (Section 305): Directors owe statutory duties to act in good faith, in the best interest of the company as a whole, and not for collateral purposes. Using board authority to extinguish staff equity incentives to entrench executive control constitutes an abuse of fiduciary power.
- Unfairly Prejudicial Conduct (Sections 343 to 345): Where ESOP shares confer member rights or where employees are equitable owners, they can file an unfair prejudice petition alleging that company affairs are conducted in a manner oppressive and unfairly discriminatory to their interests.
- Derivative Actions (Section 346): If directors breach duties owed directly to the corporate entity by misapplying scheme assets, employee-shareholders can apply for court leave to bring a derivative suit in the name of the company.
- Trustees Law and Judicial Supervision: An ESOP trust created by a formal Trust Deed is irrevocable unless explicit revocation powers were expressly reserved in the deed. Trustees who execute unlawful director directives face personal liability for breach of trust.
Step-by-Step Procedure to Challenge ESOP Cancellation
Litigating an unlawful ESOP cancellation requires swift procedural execution before trust assets are transferred, diluted, or cancelled on the CAC portal:
- Inspection of Scheme Documentation: Secure certified copies of the original ESOP Scheme Rules, the registered Trust Deed, vesting schedules, individual award letters, and relevant board resolutions.
- Issuing a Formal Cease and Desist Demand: Retain legal counsel to serve a formal pre-action letter on the board of directors and the scheme trustees, putting them on formal notice of breach of trust and statutory violations.
- Filing an Originating Summons at Federal High Court: Institute proceedings at the Federal High Court seeking judicial construction of the Trust Deed and declarations that the cancellation resolution is null, void, and ultra vires.
- Applying for Interlocutory Injunctions: File an urgent motion for interlocutory injunction restraining the company, directors, and CAC from registering any changes to the company’s register of members or cancelling the disputed share certificates.
- Petitioning Sector Regulators: If the company is a listed public firm or capital market operator, file a formal complaint with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Enforcement Department for violation of SEC Rules on employee share schemes.
Judicial Remedies Available to Aggrieved Employees
The Federal High Court exercises broad equitable powers under Section 345 of CAMA 2020 to fashion corrective relief tailored to corporate abuse:
- Order Setting Aside the Board Resolution: The court can formally quash the directors’ resolution attempting to dissolve the scheme or forfeit employee allocations.
- Restitution and Asset Reconstitution: Ordering the company and complicit trustees to restore the full block of ordinary shares to the ESOP trust account.
- Removal and Replacement of Complicit Trustees: Disqualifying the existing scheme trustees and appointing independent institutional trustees to oversee scheme vesting and dividend distribution.
- Compulsory Buyout at Fair Market Value: Directing the company or majority shareholders to purchase the beneficiaries’ vested equity interest at independent valuation certified by court-approved forensic accountants.
- General and Special Damages: Awarding damages against individual directors for lost interim dividends, interest, and economic losses caused by unlawful scheme interference.
Corporate Preventive Measures
Companies structuring ESOPs should appoint professional institutional trustees rather than internal executive directors to insulate the trust from boardroom conflicts. Trust Deeds must include clear dispute resolution mechanisms and independent arbitration clauses to resolve vesting interpretations fairly.
Prompt judicial intervention safeguards employee equity rights, preserves corporate morale, and ensures corporate directors remain accountable to established fiduciary standards under Nigerian corporate law.