Under Sections 658 through 661 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 (CAMA), a court-appointed or creditors’ liquidator defending against or resisting challenge to clawback and fraudulent preference actions must establish that the challenged disposition was executed in good faith, for valuable consideration, and in the ordinary course of business. The liquidator must demonstrate that the debtor company did not possess the statutory desire to prefer the recipient creditor over other unsecured creditors within the statutory vulnerability period preceding the insolvency commencement date.
Clawback litigation in corporate liquidation balances the recovery of dissipated assets for the general body of creditors against the commercial certainty of bona fide pre-liquidation transactions. When unsecured creditors or disgruntled stakeholders allege unlawful preference, liquidators must apply precise statutory tests under CAMA 2020 to establish whether transactions are voidable or legally enforceable.
Statutory Grounds for Unfair Preferences Under Section 658
Section 658 of CAMA 2020 replaces the common law doctrine of fraudulent conveyance with an objective test of unfair preference. A transaction constitutes an unfair preference if it satisfies three concurrent statutory elements:
- Timing Within the Vulnerability Period: The transaction must have occurred within three months prior to the commencement of winding up, or within two years if the transaction involved a person connected with the company such as a director, shadow director, or corporate affiliate.
- Insolvency at the Time of Transaction: The company must have been unable to pay its debts within the meaning of Section 572 of CAMA 2020 at the date of the disposition, or became insolvent as a consequence of entering into the transaction.
- Improvement of Creditor Position: The disposition must have placed the recipient creditor, surety, or guarantor in a better position than they would have occupied in a formal winding-up distribution.
Statutory Defences Available to Defend Challenged Transactions
When defending a transaction or resisting claims that a pre-insolvency deal was an unlawful preference, the liquidator or transferee must rely on explicit statutory safe harbours recognized under Nigerian insolvency jurisprudence:
- Absence of Desire to Prefer: Section 658(5) requires proof that the debtor company was positively influenced by a desire to produce the statutory preferential effect. If the transfer was driven by genuine, unyielding commercial pressure, threatened litigation, or urgent asset protection demands from the creditor, the requisite subjective desire is legally negated.
- Ordinary Course of Business Defence: Payments made under routine terms of trade, such as recurring utility payments, standard employee wages, or scheduled trade supply invoices, do not constitute preferences if executed without intent to bypass collective insolvency distribution.
- Transactions for Full Market Value: Transactions at an undervalue under Section 659 can be defeated by proving the company entered into the transaction in good faith for the purpose of carrying on its business, with reasonable grounds for believing the transaction would benefit the company.
- Valid Consideration for Floating Charges: Under Section 661, a floating charge created within twelve months of insolvency is valid to the extent of cash paid to the company at the time of or subsequently in consideration for the charge, together with interest at statutory rates.
Procedural Duties and Evidentiary Burdens Before the Federal High Court
The Federal High Court holds exclusive jurisdiction over corporate winding-up and insolvency proceedings under Section 251(1)(e) of the 1999 Constitution and CAMA 2020. Liquidators defending clawback claims must follow structured litigation protocols:
- Forensic Accounting Reconstruction: The liquidator must present certified books of account, bank transaction logs, and board meeting minutes to prove the exact cash solvency position on the execution date.
- Burden of Proof Allocation: While the party alleging a preference bears the initial burden of proving the statutory vulnerability timeline and insolvency status, the recipient bears the burden of establishing the good faith commercial defence.
- Committee of Inspection Consultation: Liquidators must document formal consultation with the Committee of Inspection or obtain court sanction under Section 588 of CAMA 2020 before compromising or defending complex preference claims.
- Protection of Subsequent Third-Party Purchasers: Under Section 658(8), where a third party acquired property in good faith and for valuable consideration from the preferred creditor, the court cannot order forfeiture of the asset against the innocent third party.
Strategic Risk Management for Insolvency Practitioners
Insolvency practitioners appointed as liquidators must exercise extreme care to avoid personal cost orders when defending dubious transactions. Liquidators should obtain independent legal opinions assessing the prospects of clawback litigation before dissipating estate funds on lengthy appeals.
By applying the objective standards of CAMA 2020 and securing clear forensic evidence of commercial justification, liquidators effectively defend legitimate pre-insolvency corporate transactions while preserving dividend distributions for genuine unsecured creditors.