Under Section 222 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA 2020), a debenture trust deed and any associated charge created by a company over its undertaking or assets must be registered with the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) within 90 days after the date of its creation. Failure to register the debenture trust deed within this statutory 90-day window renders the security void against an appointed liquidator, administrator, or any competing creditor of the company, leaving the debenture holder as an unsecured creditor.
The Nature and Commercial Role of Debenture Trust Deeds
A debenture trust deed is a formal legal contract executed between a borrowing company and a designated corporate trustee who holds security rights on behalf of syndicated lenders, commercial banks, or public bondholders. The deed creates fixed charges over specific assets like land and machinery, alongside floating charges over circulating assets such as trade inventory and book debts.
Registration with the CAC serves as constructive legal notice to the global business community. Once registered on the CAC charges portal, any subsequent lender or purchaser is legally presumed to have notice of the prior encumbrance over the company assets.
Statutory Filing Deadlines Under CAMA 2020 Versus Repealed Law
CAMA 2020 introduced significant reform regarding filing timeframes. Under the repealed 1990 Act, companies had an extremely tight deadline of 21 days to register corporate charges. Section 222 of CAMA 2020 extended this statutory window to 90 days from the date of execution of the security instrument.
The 90-day timeline is strict and calculated consecutively from the date the deed is signed and sealed by the parties. If the deed is executed outside Nigeria over foreign property or cross-border assets, the 90-day period begins from the date the instrument could have reached Nigeria with due dispatch.
Legal Consequences of Non-Registration Within 90 Days
Failing to lodge the debenture trust deed within the 90-day statutory timeline triggers immediate statutory repercussions under CAMA 2020:
- Loss of Security Priority: The charge becomes completely void against any liquidator, receiver, business administrator, or execution creditor of the company. The lenders lose their preferential secured recovery status.
- Immediate Acceleration of Debt: Under Section 222(2) of CAMA 2020, when a charge becomes void for lack of timely registration, the underlying loan money secured by the debenture immediately becomes due and payable by the borrowing company.
- Subordination to Subsequent Registered Charges: If a subsequent lender executes a mortgage or charge over the same assets and registers it within 90 days, the subsequent lender takes legal priority over the unregistered earlier debenture.
Court Extension of Time and Rectification Under Section 224
Where the 90-day deadline elapses without registration, the CAC portal will reject standard electronic submission. The parties cannot cure the defect administratively; they must file a formal application before the Federal High Court pursuant to Section 224 of CAMA 2020.
The court will grant an order extending the time for registration only where the applicant proves that the failure to register was accidental, due to inadvertence or other sufficient cause, or that an extension will not prejudice the position of existing creditors or shareholders. Once the court order is enrolled, it must be uploaded to the CAC portal with the prescribed penalty fees.
Filing Fees, Stamp Duties, and Electronic Registration Procedure
Registering a debenture trust deed requires a systematic process through the CAC Company Registration Portal (CRP) and tax channels:
- Stamping with the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS): Submit the debenture deed for stamp duty assessment. Under the Stamp Duties Act, ad valorem stamp duty must be settled on the principal debt value via Remita before CAC submission.
- Filing Form CAC 9 (Notice of Charge): Complete the electronic form on the CAC portal, stating the borrowing company registration number, trustee details, date of creation, total debt secured, and detailed asset description.
- Uploading Supporting Documents: Upload the duly stamped debenture trust deed, board resolutions authorizing the borrowing, and trustee assent documents.
- Payment of CAC Filing Fees: Settle the CAC statutory filing fees calculated based on the total secured borrowing amount under CAC operational schedules.
- Issuance of Certificate of Registration: Download the statutory Certificate of Registration of Charge issued by the Registrar-General, confirming the registration number, charge date, and priority ranking.
Internal Company Register of Charges Under Section 217
In addition to filing with the CAC, Section 217 of CAMA 2020 mandates every company to keep a register of charges at its registered office. The company secretary must enter copies of the debenture trust deed, property description, and names of trustees into this register. Failure to maintain the internal register constitutes an offense punishable by daily administrative penalties against the company and defaulting officers.