To restrain an unlawful sale of mortgaged corporate assets in Nigeria, a corporate debtor must file a substantive lawsuit supported by a motion for interlocutory injunction in the appropriate High Court. The application must establish that the mortgagee bank or receiver has acted improperly, and prove that selling the mortgaged property will cause irreparable damage to the company before the main dispute is adjudicated.
Circumstances Making a Mortgagee Sale Unlawful
While banks and institutional debenture holders possess statutory powers of sale under registered mortgage deeds, that power cannot be exercised arbitrarily. An intended sale becomes legally defective and open to judicial restraint under several defined circumstances:
- Failure to Serve Statutory Notice of Default: The lender failed to serve the mandatory statutory demand notice or allow the cure period stipulated under the mortgage deed or applicable property statutes.
- Premature Exercise of Power: The contractual power of sale has not arisen because the underlying debt has not matured or the alleged default is disputed on genuine accounting grounds.
- Unregistered Charge with CAC: Under Section 222 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, failure to register a company charge or mortgage with the CAC within 90 days of creation renders the security void against any liquidator or creditor.
- Collusion and Undervaluation: The lender or receiver seeks to sell prime corporate collateral at an unconscionable undervalue or through private collusive arrangements rather than a fair commercial valuation.
- Pending Dispute Over Accurate Indebtedness: Substantial proof exists that the lender applied excessive, unauthorized, or predatory charges that inflate the purported debt balance.
Judicial Principles Governing Injunctive Relief in Nigeria
Nigerian courts follow strict principles established by the Supreme Court in landmark authorities such as Kotoye v. CBN and Obeya Memorial Hospital v. AG Federation. To secure an interim or interlocutory injunction restraining an asset sale, the company must satisfy four legal conditions in its affidavit evidence:
- Prima Facie Case or Serious Question to be Tried: The company must show that the dispute is not frivolous and that substantial legal issues exist regarding the validity of the mortgage, the quantum of debt, or the conduct of the mortgagee.
- Irreparable Harm: The company must demonstrate that if the commercial plant, industrial real estate, or operating assets are sold, monetary damages will not adequately compensate the resulting business destruction.
- Balance of Convenience: The court weighs which party will suffer greater hardship. The company must prove that retaining the status quo causes less injury to the secured lender than an immediate sale would inflict on the debtor enterprise.
- Undertaking as to Damages: The applicant company must explicitly offer a solemn written undertaking to indemnify the lender for any financial losses suffered if the court ultimately finds the injunction was obtained without merit.
Procedural Steps to File the Court Injunction
Corporate legal counsel must act swiftly to arrest imminent asset disposals through the following litigation stages:
- Drafting the Originating Court Processes: Prepare a Writ of Summons alongside a Statement of Claim, or an Originating Summons, detailing the facts of the credit facility, disputed figures, and explicit declarations that the threatened sale is unlawful.
- Filing Motion Ex-Parte for Interim Injunction: Where the lender or auctioneer has posted sale notices or scheduled an auction within days, file an urgent ex-parte motion seeking a short-term order preserving the res until the other party can be heard.
- Filing Motion on Notice for Interlocutory Injunction: Accompany the filings with a Motion on Notice for an interlocutory injunction that will preserve the corporate assets throughout the entire duration of the substantive lawsuit.
- Affidavit of Urgency and Supporting Documents: Depose to a comprehensive affidavit exhibiting the loan documentation, bank statements, objection letters, expert audit reports showing inflated charges, and proof of impending auction.
- Service of Court Processes on All Adverse Parties: Serve the sealed processes promptly on the lending bank, the appointed receiver-manager, and the registered auctioneer to establish formal notice and invoke the doctrine of lis pendens.
The Strategic Impact of Lis Pendens and CAC Notification
Once court processes challenging the mortgage enforcement are formally served on the lender and auctioneer, the doctrine of lis pendens takes immediate operational effect. Under this doctrine, any third party who purports to purchase the mortgaged asset while the lawsuit is pending does so at their own peril, subject to the final outcome of the suit.
To reinforce protection, the company should also file a formal notice of pending litigation with the Corporate Affairs Commission and the state lands registry where the corporate property is registered. This notification alerts prospective buyers and regulatory authorities that title to the corporate assets is subject to ongoing judicial contest.